EN FR
EN FR

2025Activity report​​Project-TeamTROPICAL

RNSR: 201621988K​​​‌
  • Research center Inria Saclay​ Centre
  • Team name: Tropical​‌ methods: structures, algorithms and​​ interactions
  • In collaboration with:​​​‌Centre de Mathématiques Appliquées​ (CMAP)

Creation of the​‌ Project-Team: 2018 July 01​​

Each year, Inria research​​​‌ teams publish an Activity​ Report presenting their work​‌ and results over the​​ reporting period. These reports​​​‌ follow a common structure,​ with some optional sections​‌ depending on the specific​​ team. They typically begin​​​‌ by outlining the overall​ objectives and research programme,​‌ including the main research​​ themes, goals, and methodological​​​‌ approaches. They also describe​ the application domains targeted​‌ by the team, highlighting​​ the scientific or societal​​​‌ contexts in which their​ work is situated.

The​‌ reports then present the​​ highlights of the year,​​​‌ covering major scientific achievements,​ software developments, or teaching​‌ contributions. When relevant, they​​ include sections on software,​​​‌ platforms, and open data,​ detailing the tools developed​‌ and how they are​​ shared. A substantial part​​​‌ is dedicated to new​ results, where scientific contributions​‌ are described in detail,​​ often with subsections specifying​​​‌ participants and associated keywords.​

Finally, the Activity Report​‌ addresses funding, contracts, partnerships,​​ and collaborations at various​​​‌ levels, from industrial agreements​ to international cooperations. It​‌ also covers dissemination and​​ teaching activities, such as​​​‌ participation in scientific events,​ outreach, and supervision. The​‌ document concludes with a​​ presentation of scientific production,​​​‌ including major publications and​ those produced during the​‌ year.

Keywords

Computer Science​​ and Digital Science

  • A1.2.4.​​​‌ QoS, performance evaluation
  • A2.3.3.​ Real-time systems
  • A4.5. Formal​‌ method for verification, reliability,​​ certification
  • A6.2.5. Numerical Linear​​​‌ Algebra
  • A6.2.6. Optimization
  • A6.4.2.​ Stochastic control
  • A6.4.6. Optimal​‌ control
  • A7.2.4. Mechanized Formalization​​ of Mathematics
  • A8.1. Discrete​​​‌ mathematics, combinatorics
  • A8.2.1. Operations​ research
  • A8.3. Geometry, Topology​‌
  • A8.4. Computer Algebra
  • A8.9.​​ Performance evaluation
  • A8.11. Game​​​‌ Theory
  • A9.6. Decision support​

Other Research Topics and​‌ Application Domains

  • B4.3. Renewable​​ energy production
  • B4.4. Energy​​​‌ delivery
  • B4.4.1. Smart grids​
  • B6.6. Embedded systems
  • B8.4.​‌ Security and personal assistance​​
  • B8.4.1. Crisis management

1​​​‌ Team members, visitors, external​ collaborators

Research Scientists

  • Stephane​‌ Gaubert [Team leader​​, INRIA, Senior​​​‌ Researcher, HDR]​
  • Marianne Akian [INRIA​‌, Senior Researcher,​​ HDR]
  • Xavier Allamigeon​​​‌ [Inria, Researcher​, Corps des Mines,​‌ under secondment]
  • Matías​​ Bender [INRIA,​​​‌ Researcher]
  • Cormac Walsh​ [INRIA, Researcher​‌]

PhD Students

  • Amanda​​ Bigel [UNIV MONTPELLIER​​​‌, from Sep 2025​]
  • Amanda Bigel [​‌INRIA, until Aug​​ 2025]
  • Abdellah Bulaich​​​‌ Mehamdi [ECOLE POLY​ PALAISEAU, CIFRE]​‌
  • Pascal Capetillo [INRIA​​]
  • Yiyuan Chen [​​ECOLE POLY PALAISEAU]​​​‌
  • Luca Froger [INRIA‌]
  • Jonathan Hornewall [‌​‌ECOLE POLY PALAISEAU]​​
  • Loic Marchesini [ECOLE​​​‌ POLY PALAISEAU]
  • Jad‌ Zeroual [ORANGE LABS‌​‌, CIFRE]

Interns​​ and Apprentices

  • Hanqi Sun​​​‌ [INRIA, Intern‌, from Apr 2025‌​‌ until Jul 2025]​​

Administrative Assistants

  • Bahar Carabetta​​​‌ [INRIA, from‌ Dec 2025]
  • Amandine‌​‌ Sainsard [INRIA,​​ until Nov 2025]​​​‌

Visiting Scientist

  • Gleb Koshevoi‌ [Russian Academy of‌​‌ Science, from Feb​​ 2025 until Apr 2025​​​‌]

2 Overall objectives‌

The project develops tropical‌​‌ methods motivated by applications​​ arising in decision theory​​​‌ (deterministic and stochastic optimal‌ control, game theory, optimization‌​‌ and operations research), in​​ the analysis or control​​​‌ of classes of dynamical‌ systems (including timed discrete‌​‌ event systems and positive​​ systems), in the verification​​​‌ of programs and systems,‌ and in the development‌​‌ of numerical algorithms. Tropical​​ algebra tools are used​​​‌ in interaction with various‌ methods, coming from convex‌​‌ analysis, Hamilton–Jacobi partial differential​​ equations, metric geometry, Perron-Frobenius​​​‌ and nonlinear fixed-point theories,‌ combinatorics or algorithmic complexity.‌​‌ The emphasis of the​​ project is on mathematical​​​‌ modelling and computational aspects.‌

The subtitle of the‌​‌ Tropical project, namely, “structures,​​ algorithms, and interactions”, refers​​​‌ to the spirit of‌ our research, including a‌​‌ methodological component, computational aspects,​​ and finally interactions with​​​‌ other scientific fields or‌ real world applications, in‌​‌ particular through mathematical modelling.​​

2.1 Scientific context

Tropical​​​‌ algebra, geometry, and analysis‌ have enjoyed spectacular development‌​‌ in recent years. Tropical​​ structures initially arose to​​​‌ solve problems in performance‌ evaluation of discrete event‌​‌ systems  68, combinatorial​​ optimization  75, or​​​‌ automata theory  114.‌ They also arose in‌​‌ mathematical physics and asymptotic​​ analysis  105, 100​​​‌. More recently, these‌ structures have appeared in‌​‌ several areas of pure​​ mathematics, in particular in​​​‌ the study of combinatorial‌ aspects of algebraic geometry‌​‌  91, 129,​​ 119, 99,​​​‌ in algebraic combinatorics  85‌, and in arithmetics‌​‌  79. Also, further​​ applications of tropical methods​​​‌ have appeared, including optimal‌ control  106, program‌​‌ invariant computation  62 and​​ timed systems verification  104​​​‌, and zero-sum games‌ 2.

The term‌​‌ `tropical' generally refers to​​ algebraic structures in which​​​‌ the laws originate from‌ optimization processes. The prototypical‌​‌ tropical structure is the​​ max-plus semifield, consisting of​​​‌ the real numbers, equipped‌ with the maximum, thought‌​‌ of as an additive​​ law, and the addition,​​​‌ thought of as a‌ multiplicative law. Tropical objects‌​‌ appear as limits of​​ classical objects along certain​​​‌ deformations (“log-limits sets” of‌ Bergman, “Maslov dequantization”, or‌​‌ “Viro deformation”). For this​​ reason, the introduction of​​​‌ tropical tools often yields‌ new insights into old‌​‌ familiar problems, leading either​​ to counterexamples or to​​​‌ new methods and results;‌ see for instance  129‌​‌, 110. In​​ some applications, like optimal​​​‌ control, discrete event systems,‌ or static analysis of‌​‌ programs, tropical objects do​​ not appear through a​​​‌ limit procedure, but more‌ directly as a modelling‌​‌ or computation/analysis tool; see​​​‌ for instance  124,​ 68, 95,​‌ 76.

Tropical methods​​ are linked to the​​​‌ fields of positive systems​ and of metric geometry​‌  112, 12.​​ Indeed, tropically linear maps​​​‌ are monotone (a.k.a. order-preserving).​ They are also nonexpansive​‌ in certain natural metrics​​ (sup-norm, Hopf oscillation, Hilbert's​​​‌ projective metric, ...). In​ this way, tropical dynamical​‌ systems appear to be​​ special cases of nonexpansive,​​​‌ positive, or monotone dynamical​ systems, which are studied​‌ as part of linear​​ and non-linear Perron-Frobenius theory​​​‌  101, 3.​ Such dynamical systems are​‌ of fundamental importance in​​ the study of repeated​​​‌ games  109. Monotonicity​ properties are also essential​‌ in the understanding of​​ the fixed points problems​​​‌ which determine program invariants​ by abstract interpretation  80​‌. The latter problems​​ are actually somehow similar​​​‌ to the ones arising​ in the study of​‌ zero-sum games; see 7​​. Moreover, positivity or​​​‌ monotonicity methods are useful​ in population dynamics, either​‌ in a discrete space​​ setting  125 or in​​​‌ a PDE setting  70​. In such cases,​‌ solving tropical problems often​​ leads to solutions or​​​‌ combinatorial insights on classical​ problems involving positivity conditions​‌ (e.g., finding equilibria of​​ dynamical systems with nonnegative​​​‌ coordinates, understanding the qualitative​ and quantitative behavior of​‌ growth rates / Floquet​​ eigenvalues 10, etc).​​​‌ Other applications of Perron-Frobenius​ theory originate from quantum​‌ information and control  118​​, 123.

3​​​‌ Research program

3.1 Optimal​ control and zero-sum games​‌

The dynamic programming approach​​ allows one to analyze​​​‌ one or two-player dynamic​ decision problems by means​‌ of operators, or partial​​ differential equations (Hamilton–Jacobi or​​​‌ Isaacs PDEs), describing the​ time evolution of the​‌ value function, i.e., of​​ the optimal reward of​​​‌ one player, thought of​ as a function of​‌ the initial state and​​ of the horizon. We​​​‌ work especially with problems​ having long or infinite​‌ horizon, modelled by stopping​​ problems, or ergodic problems​​​‌ in which one optimizes​ a mean payoff per​‌ time unit. The determination​​ of optimal strategies reduces​​​‌ to solving nonlinear fixed​ point equations, which are​‌ obtained either directly from​​ discrete models, or after​​​‌ a discretization of a​ PDE.

The geometry of​‌ solutions of optimal control​​ and game problems Basic​​​‌ questions include, especially for​ stationary or ergodic problems,​‌ the understanding of existence​​ and uniqueness conditions for​​​‌ the solutions of dynamic​ programming equations, for instance​‌ in terms of controllability​​ or ergodicity properties, and​​​‌ more generally the understanding​ of the structure of​‌ the full set of​​ solutions of stationary Hamilton–Jacobi​​​‌ PDEs and of the​ set of optimal strategies.​‌ These issues are already​​ challenging in the one-player​​​‌ deterministic case, which is​ an application of choice​‌ of tropical methods, since​​ the Lax-Oleinik semigroup, i.e.,​​​‌ the evolution semigroup of​ the Hamilton-Jacobi PDE, is​‌ a linear operator in​​ the tropical sense. Recent​​​‌ progress in the deterministic​ case has been made​‌ by combining dynamical systems​​ and PDE techniques (weak​​​‌ KAM theory  82),​ and also using metric​‌ geometry ideas (abstract boundaries​​ can be used to​​ represent the sets of​​​‌ solutions 98, 4‌). The two player‌​‌ case is challenging, owing​​ to the lack of​​​‌ compactness of the analogue‌ of the Lax-Oleinik semigroup‌​‌ and to a richer​​ geometry. The conditions of​​​‌ solvability of ergodic problems‌ for games (for instance,‌​‌ solvability of ergodic Isaacs​​ PDEs), and the representation​​​‌ of solutions are only‌ understood in special cases,‌​‌ for instance in the​​ finite state space case,​​​‌ through tropical geometry and‌ non-linear Perron-Frobenius methods  48‌​‌, 41, 3​​.

Algorithmic aspects: from​​​‌ combinatorial algorithms to the‌ attenuation of the curse‌​‌ of dimensionality Our general​​ goal is to push​​​‌ the limits of solvable‌ models by means of‌​‌ fast algorithms adapted to​​ large scale instances. Such​​​‌ instances arise from discrete‌ problems, in which the‌​‌ state space may so​​ large that it is​​​‌ only accessible through local‌ oracles (for instance, in‌​‌ some web ranking applications,​​ the number of states​​​‌ may be the number‌ of web pages)  83‌​‌. They also arise​​ from the discretization of​​​‌ PDEs, in which the‌ number of states grows‌​‌ exponentially with the number​​ of degrees of freedom,​​​‌ according to the “curse‌ of dimensionality”. A first‌​‌ line of research is​​ the development of new​​​‌ approximation methods for the‌ value function. So‌​‌ far, classical approximations by​​ linear combinations have been​​​‌ used, as well as‌ approximation by suprema of‌​‌ linear or quadratic forms,​​ which have been introduced​​​‌ in the setting of‌ dual dynamic programming and‌​‌ of the so called​​ “max-plus basis methods”  84​​​‌. We believe that‌ more concise or more‌​‌ accurate approximations may be​​ obtained by unifying these​​​‌ methods. Also, some max-plus‌ basis methods have been‌​‌ shown to attenuate the​​ curse of dimensionality for​​​‌ very special problems (for‌ instance involving switching)  107‌​‌, 87. This​​ suggests that the complexity​​​‌ of control or games‌ problems may be measured‌​‌ by more subtle quantities​​ that the mere number​​​‌ of states, for instance,‌ by some forms of‌​‌ metric entropy (for example,​​ certain large scale problems​​​‌ have a low complexity‌ owing to the presence‌​‌ of decomposition properties, “highway​​ hierarchies”, etc.). A second​​​‌ line of of our‌ research is the development‌​‌ of combinatorial algorithms,​​ to solve large scale​​​‌ zero-sum two-player problems with‌ discrete state space. This‌​‌ is related to current​​ open problems in algorithmic​​​‌ game theory. In particular,‌ the existence of polynomial-time‌​‌ algorithms for games with​​ ergodic payment is an​​​‌ open question. See e.g.‌  52 for a polynomial‌​‌ time average complexity result​​ derived by tropical methods.​​​‌ The two lines of‌ research are related, as‌​‌ the understanding of the​​ geometry of solutions allows​​​‌ to develop better approximation‌ or combinatorial algorithms.

3.2‌​‌ Non-linear Perron-Frobenius theory, nonexpansive​​ mappings and metric geometry​​​‌

Several applications (including population‌ dynamics 10 and discrete‌​‌ event systems 68,​​ 78, 53)​​​‌ lead to studying classes‌ of dynamical systems with‌​‌ remarkable properties: preserving a​​ cone, preserving an order,​​​‌ or being nonexpansive in‌ a metric. These can‌​‌ be studied by techniques​​​‌ of non-linear Perron-Frobenius theory​ 3 or metric geometry​‌ 11. Basic issues​​ concern the existence and​​​‌ computation of the “escape​ rate” (which determines the​‌ throughput, the growth rate​​ of the population), the​​​‌ characterizations of stationary regimes​ (non-linear fixed points), or​‌ the study of the​​ dynamical properties (convergence to​​​‌ periodic orbits). Nonexpansive mappings​ also play a key​‌ role in the “operator​​ approach” to zero-sum games,​​​‌ since the one-day operators​ of games are nonexpansive​‌ in several metrics, see​​ 8.

3.3 Tropical​​​‌ algebra and convex geometry​

The different applications mentioned​‌ in the other sections​​ lead us to develop​​​‌ some basic research on​ tropical algebraic structures and​‌ in convex and discrete​​ geometry, looking at objects​​​‌ or problems with a​ “piecewise-linear ” structure. These​‌ include the geometry and​​ algorithmics of tropical convex​​​‌ sets 61,2​, tropical semialgebraic sets​‌  65, the study​​ of semi-modules (analogues of​​​‌ vector spaces when the​ base field is replaced​‌ by a semi-field), the​​ study of systems of​​​‌ equations linear in the​ tropical sense, investigating for​‌ instance the analogues of​​ the notions of rank,​​​‌ the analogue of the​ eigenproblems  47, and​‌ more generally of systems​​ of tropical polynomial equations.​​​‌ Our research also builds​ on, and concern, classical​‌ convex and discrete geometry​​ methods.

3.4 Tropical methods​​​‌ applied to optimization, perturbation​ theory and matrix analysis​‌

Tropical algebraic objects appear​​ as a deformation of​​​‌ classical objects thought various​ asymptotic procedures. A familiar​‌ example is the rule​​ of asymptotic calculus,

e​​​‌ - a / ϵ​ + e - b​‌ / ϵ e​​ - min ( a​​​‌ , b ) /​ ϵ , e -​‌ a / ϵ ×​​ e - b /​​​‌ ϵ = e -​ ( a + b​‌ ) / ϵ ,​​ 1

when ϵ→​​​‌0+. Deformations​ of this kind have​‌ been studied in different​​ contexts: large deviations, zero-temperature​​​‌ limits, Maslov's “dequantization method”​  105, non-archimedean valuations,​‌ log-limit sets and Viro's​​ patchworking method  129,​​​‌ etc.

This entails a​ relation between classical algorithmic​‌ problems and tropical algorithmic​​ problems, one may first​​​‌ solve the ϵ=​0 case (non-archimedean problem),​‌ which is sometimes easier,​​ and then use the​​​‌ information gotten in this​ way to solve the​‌ ϵ=1 (archimedean)​​ case.

In particular, tropicalization​​​‌ establishes a connection between​ polynomial systems and piecewise​‌ affine systems that are​​ somehow similar to the​​​‌ ones arising in game​ problems. It allows one​‌ to transfer results from​​ the world of combinatorics​​​‌ to “classical” equations solving.​ We investigate the consequences​‌ of this correspondence on​​ complexity and numerical issues.​​​‌ For instance, combinatorial problems​ can be solved in​‌ a robust way. Hence,​​ situations in which the​​​‌ tropicalization is faithful lead​ to improved algorithms for​‌ classical problems. In particular,​​ scalings for the polynomial​​​‌ eigenproblems based on tropical​ preprocessings have started to​‌ be used in matrix​​ analysis  88, 94​​​‌.

Moreover, the tropical​ approach has been recently​‌ applied to construct examples​​ of linear programs in​​ which the central path​​​‌ has an unexpectedly high‌ total curvature 51,‌​‌6, and it​​ has also led to​​​‌ positive polynomial-time average case‌ results concerning the complexity‌​‌ of mean payoff games.​​ Similarly, we are studying​​​‌ semidefinite programming over non-archimedean‌ fields 65, 64‌​‌, with the goal​​ to better understand complexity​​​‌ issues in classical semidefinite‌ and semi-algebraic programming.

4‌​‌ Application domains

4.1 Discrete​​ event systems (manufacturing systems,​​​‌ networks, emergency call centers)‌

One important class of‌​‌ applications of max-plus algebra​​ comes from discrete event​​​‌ dynamical systems  68.‌ In particular, modelling timed‌​‌ systems subject to synchronization​​ and concurrency phenomena leads​​​‌ to studying dynamical systems‌ that are non-smooth, but‌​‌ which have remarkable structural​​ properties (nonexpansiveness in certain​​​‌ metrics , monotonicity) or‌ combinatorial properties. Algebraic methods‌​‌ allow one to obtain​​ analytical expressions for performance​​​‌ measures (throughput, waiting time,‌ etc). A recent application,‌​‌ to emergency call centers,​​ can be found in​​​‌  53.

4.2 Optimal‌ control and games

Optimal‌​‌ control and game theory​​ have numerous well established​​​‌ applications fields: mathematical economy‌ and finance, stock optimization,‌​‌ optimization of networks, decision​​ making, etc. In most​​​‌ of these applications, one‌ needs either to derive‌​‌ analytical or qualitative properties​​ of solutions, or design​​​‌ exact or approximation algorithms‌ adapted to large scale‌​‌ problems.

4.3 Operations Research​​

We develop, or have​​​‌ developed, several aspects of‌ operations research, including the‌​‌ application of stochastic control​​ to optimal pricing, optimal​​​‌ measurement in networks  120‌. Applications of tropical‌​‌ methods arise in particular​​ from discrete optimization  76​​​‌77, scheduling‌ problems with and-or constraints‌​‌  111, or product​​ mix auctions  127.​​​‌

4.4 Computing program and‌ dynamical systems invariants

A‌​‌ number of programs and​​ systems verification questions, in​​​‌ which safety considerations are‌ involved, reduce to computing‌​‌ invariant subsets of dynamical​​ systems. This approach appears​​​‌ in various guises in‌ computer science, for instance‌​‌ in static analysis of​​ program by abstract interpretation,​​​‌ along the lines of‌ P. and R. Cousot‌​‌  80, but also​​ in control (eg, computing​​​‌ safety regions by solving‌ Isaacs PDEs). These invariant‌​‌ sets are often sought​​ in some tractable effective​​​‌ class: ellipsoids, polyhedra, parametric‌ classes of polyhedra with‌​‌ a controlled complexity (the​​ so called “templates” introduced​​​‌ by Sankaranarayanan, Sipma and‌ Manna  122), shadows‌​‌ of sets represented by​​ linear matrix inequalities, disjunctive​​​‌ constraints represented by tropical‌ polyhedra  62, etc.‌​‌ The computation of invariants​​ boils down to solving​​​‌ large scale fixed point‌ problems. The latter are‌​‌ of the same nature​​ as the ones encountered​​​‌ in the theory of‌ zero-sum games, and so,‌​‌ the techniques developed in​​ the previous research directions​​​‌ (especially methods of monotonicity,‌ nonexpansiveness, discretization of PDEs,‌​‌ etc) apply to the​​ present setting, see e.g.​​​‌  86, 90 for‌ the application of policy‌​‌ iteration type algorithms, or​​ for the application for​​​‌ fixed point problems over‌ the space of quadratic‌​‌ forms 7. The​​ problem of computation of​​​‌ invariants is indeed a‌ key issue needing the‌​‌ methods of several fields:​​​‌ convex and nonconvex programming,​ semidefinite programming and symbolic​‌ computation (to handle semialgebraic​​ invariants), nonlinear fixed point​​​‌ theory, approximation theory, tropical​ methods (to handle disjunctions),​‌ and formal proof (to​​ certify numerical invariants or​​​‌ inequalities).

5 Social and​ environmental responsibility

5.1 Impact​‌ of research results

The​​ team has developed collaborations​​​‌ on the dimensioning of​ emergency call centers, with​‌ Préfecture de Police (Plate​​ Forme d'Appels d'Urgence -​​​‌ PFAU - 17-18-112, operated​ jointly by Brigade de​‌ sapeurs pompiers de Paris​​ and by Direction de​​​‌ la sécurité de proximité​ de l'agglomération parisienne) and​‌ also with the Emergency​​ medical services of Assistance​​​‌ Publique – Hôpitaux de​ Paris (Centre 15 of​‌ SAMU75, 92, 93 and​​ 94). This work is​​​‌ described further in Section​ 8.7.1. A current​‌ extension of this work​​ deals with the modelling​​​‌ of medical emergency services,​ with the project “URGE”​‌ which started at the​​ fall 2022, in the​​​‌ framework of the joint​ INRIA & AP-HP “Bernoulli”​‌ lab.

6 Highlights of​​ the year

6.1 Awards​​​‌

  • Matías Bender received the​ “Applications of Computer Algebra​‌ (ACA) Early Researcher Award”​​ 2025.

6.2 Other highlights​​​‌

  • Joint Inria-CWI associate team​ started in 2025.
  • ANR​‌ collaborative research project (PRC)​​ ZADyG, Zoology of Algorithmic​​​‌ Methods for Dynamic Games​ (CE48) accepted in 2025,​‌ coordinated by Marianne Akian.​​
  • Young researcher ANR project​​​‌ PeACE, Polynômes et Applications​ via Calculs Efficace (CE48)​‌ accepted in 2025, coordinated​​ by Matías Bender.
  • Xavier​​​‌ Allamigeon gave a plenary​ talk at the conference​‌ ROADEF 2025.
  • The articles​​ 26, 25 give​​​‌ sufficient condition for the​ existence of stationary regimes​‌ of piece-wise linear dynamical​​ systems representing priorities, as​​​‌ well as an algorithm​ to compute then. This​‌ yields a partial answer​​ to an open question​​​‌ raised in 1999, see​ 116.

7 Latest​‌ software developments, platforms, open​​ data

7.1 Latest software​​​‌ developments

7.1.1 Coq-Polyhedra

  • Name:​
    Coq-Polyhedra
  • Keywords:
    Coq, Polyhedra,​‌ Automated theorem proving, Linear​​ optimization
  • Scientific Description:

    Coq-Polyhedra​​​‌ is a library providing​ a formalization of convex​‌ polyhedra in the Coq​​ proof assistant. While still​​​‌ in active development, it​ provides an implementation of​‌ the simplex method, and​​ already handles the basic​​​‌ properties of polyhedra such​ as emptiness, boundedness, membership.​‌ Several fundamental results in​​ the theory of convex​​​‌ polyhedra, such as Farkas​ Lemma, duality theorem of​‌ linear programming, and Minkowski​​ Theorem, are also formally​​​‌ proved.

    The formalization is​ based on the Mathematical​‌ Components library, and makes​​ an extensive use of​​​‌ the boolean reflection methodology.​

  • Functional Description:
    Coq-Polyhedra is​‌ a library which aims​​ at formalizing convex polyhedra​​​‌ in Coq
  • URL:
  • Publications:
  • Contact:
    Xavier​​​‌ Allamigeon
  • Participants:
    Xavier Allamigeon,​ Quentin Canu, Ricardo Katz,​‌ Pierre-Yves Strub
  • Partners:
    CIFASIS,​​ Ecole Polytechnique

7.1.2 EmergencyEval​​​‌

  • Keywords:
    Dynamic Analysis, Simulation,​ Ocaml, Emergency, Firefighters, Police​‌
  • Scientific Description:

    This software​​ aims at enabling the​​​‌ definition of a Petri​ network execution semantic, as​‌ well as the instanciation​​ and execution of said​​​‌ network using the aforedefined​ semantic.

    The heart of​‌ the project dwells in​​ its kernel which operates​​ the step-by-step execution of​​​‌ the network, obeying rules‌ provided by an oracle.‌​‌ This user-defined and separated​​ oracle computes the information​​​‌ necessary to the kernel‌ for building the next‌​‌ state using the current​​ state. The base of​​​‌ our software is the‌ framework for the instanciation‌​‌ and execution of Petri​​ nets, without making assumptions​​​‌ regarding the semantic.

    In‌ the context of the‌​‌ study of the dynamics​​ of emergency call centers,​​​‌ a second part of‌ this software is the‌​‌ definition and implementation of​​ the semantic of call​​​‌ centers modelized as Petri‌ nets, and more specifically‌​‌ timed prioritized Petri nets.​​ A module interoperating with​​​‌ the kernel enables to‌ include all the operational‌​‌ specificities of call centers​​ (urgency level, discriminating between​​​‌ operators and callers ...)‌ while guaranteeing the genericity‌​‌ of the kernal which​​ embeds the Petri net​​​‌ formalism as such.

  • Functional‌ Description:

    In order to‌​‌ enable the quantitative study​​ of the throughput of​​​‌ calls managed by emergency‌ center calls and the‌​‌ assesment of various organisationnal​​ configurations considered by the​​​‌ stakeholders (firefighters, police, medical‌ emergency service of the‌​‌ 75, 92, 93 and​​ 94 French departments), this​​​‌ software modelizes their behaviours‌ by resorting to extensions‌​‌ of the Petri net​​ formalism. Given a call​​​‌ transfer protocol in a‌ call center, which corresponds‌​‌ to a topology and​​ an execution semantic of​​​‌ a Petri net, the‌ software generates a set‌​‌ of entering calls in​​ accord with the empirically​​​‌ observed statistic ditributions (share‌ of very urgent calls,‌​‌ conversation length), then simulates​​ its management by the​​​‌ operators with respect to‌ the defined protocol. Transitional‌​‌ regimes phenomenons (peak load,​​ support) which are not​​​‌ yet handled by mathematical‌ analysis could therefore be‌​‌ studied. The ouput of​​ the software is a​​​‌ log file which is‌ an execution trace of‌​‌ the simulation featuring extensive​​ information in order to​​​‌ enable the analysis of‌ the data for providing‌​‌ simulation-based insights for decision​​ makers.

    The software relies​​​‌ on a Petri net‌ simulation kernel designed to‌​‌ be as modular and​​ adaptable as possible, fit​​​‌ for simulating other Petri-net‌ related phenomenons, even if‌​‌ their semantic differ greatly.​​

  • Contact:
    Xavier Allamigeon
  • Participants:​​​‌
    Xavier Allamigeon, Benjamin Nguyen-Van-Yen‌

8 New results

8.1‌​‌ Optimal control and zero-sum​​ games

8.1.1 Tropical numerical​​​‌ methods for stochastic control‌ problems

Participants: Marianne Akian‌​‌.

We are interested​​ here in the numerical​​​‌ solution of the dynamic‌ programming equation of discrete‌​‌ time deterministic or stochastic​​ control problems.

In several​​​‌ works in collaboration with‌ Jean-Philippe Chancelier (CERMICS) and‌​‌ Benoit Tran, and included​​ in the PhD thesis​​​‌ of Benoit Tran 126‌, we developed and‌​‌ studied algorithms combining the​​ tropical or the max-plus​​​‌ based numerical method of‌ McEneaney 108, 106‌​‌, the stochastic max-plus​​ scheme proposed by Zheng​​​‌ Qu  117, and‌ the stochastic dual dynamic‌​‌ programming (SDDP) algorithm of​​ Pereira and Pinto 113​​​‌. In particular in‌ 15, we considered‌​‌ a stochastic algorithm for​​ deterministic control problems, and​​​‌ in 39, we‌ considered stochastic control problems.‌​‌

In an ongoing work​​​‌ with Luz Pascal (PhD​ student at Queensland University​‌ of Technology, Australia), we​​ are studying the convergence​​​‌ of SARSOP algorithm solving​ partially observable Markov Decision​‌ Process (POMDP), using the​​ same techniques as in​​​‌ 39.

8.1.2 Highway​ hierarchies for Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB)​‌ PDEs

Participants: Marianne Akian​​, Stéphane Gaubert.​​​‌

Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equations arise as​ the dynamic programming equations​‌ of deterministic or stochastic​​ optimal control problems. They​​​‌ allow to obtain the​ global optimum of these​‌ problems and to synthesize​​ an optimal feedback control,​​​‌ leading to a solution​ robust against system perturbations.​‌ Several methods have been​​ proposed in the literature​​​‌ to bypass the obstruction​ of curse of dimensionality​‌ of such equations, assuming​​ a certain structure of​​​‌ the problem, and/or using​ “unstructured discretizations”, that are​‌ not based on given​​ grids. Among them, one​​​‌ may cite tropical numerical​ method, and probabilistic numerical​‌ method. On another direction,​​ “highway hierarchies”, developed by​​​‌ Sanders, Schultes and coworkers​ 81, 121,​‌ initially for applications to​​ on-board GPS systems, are​​​‌ a computational method that​ allows one to accelerate​‌ Dijkstra algorithm for discrete​​ time and state shortest​​​‌ path problems.

In several​ works in collaboration with​‌ Shanqing Liu (now in​​ Brown University), and included​​​‌ in his PhD thesis​ 103, we have​‌ developped new numerical methods​​ to solve Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equations​​​‌ that are less sensitive​ to curse of dimensionality.​‌ In 43, we​​ have introduced a multilevel​​​‌ fast-marching method, extending to​ the PDE case the​‌ idea of “highway hierarchies”.​​ The complexity of the​​​‌ method is then analysed​ using a priori error​‌ bounds for the discretization​​ of the Hamilton-Jacobi PDE.​​​‌ In 49, we​ obtain error estimates of​‌ order 1 for the​​ semi-Lagrangian scheme of the​​​‌ Hamilton-Jacobi equation of the​ minimum time problem, under​‌ some regularity assumptions on​​ the dynamics and the​​​‌ domain. In a more​ recent work, we are​‌ extending these estimates to​​ state constrained problems in​​​‌ order to deduce the​ best complexity results for​‌ the multilevel fast-marching method.​​

8.1.3 Escape Rate Games​​​‌

Participants: Marianne Akian,​ Stéphane Gaubert, Loic​‌ Marchesini.

The aim​​ of the PhD thesis​​​‌ of Loic Marchesini is​ to study a new​‌ class of repeated zero-sum​​ games in which the​​​‌ payoff of one player​ is the escape rate​‌ of a dynamical system​​ whose dynamics depends on​​​‌ the actions of both​ players. We suppose that​‌ the dynamics obtained from​​ nonexpansive operators. Considering order​​​‌ preserving finite dimensional linear​ operators over the positive​‌ cone endowed with Hilbert's​​ projective (semi-)metric, we recover​​​‌ the matrix multiplication games​ introduced by Asarin et​‌ al. 67, which​​ generalize the joint spectral​​​‌ radius of sets of​ nonnegative matrices. See also​‌ 40. We show​​ in 44 that escape​​​‌ rate games have a​ value, which we call​‌ the competitive spectral radius​​ as it extends the​​​‌ joint spectral radius as​ well as the lower​‌ spectral rdius, corresponding to​​ “one player” special cases.​​​‌ We also characterize the​ competitive spectral radius in​‌ terms of non-linear eigenproblems,​​ providing a a two-player​​ analogue of “Mañe's Lemma”​​​‌ in ergodic control. In‌ a followup work, joint‌​‌ with Ian Morris (Queen​​ Mary, London) 24,​​​‌ we show that the‌ competivive spectral radius of‌​‌ a family of operators​​ is continuous and approximable,​​​‌ under conditions which cover‌ in particular families of‌​‌ operators sending a cone​​ to its interior.

8.1.4​​​‌ Thresholds for sensitive optimality‌ and Blackwell optimality in‌​‌ stochastic games

Participants: Stéphane​​ Gaubert.

In a​​​‌ joint work with Julien‌ Grand-Clément (HEC Paris) and‌​‌ Ricardo Katz (CIFASIS, CONICET)​​ 28, we give​​​‌ explicit bounds for the‌ threshods of sensitive optimality‌​‌ and Blackwell optimality in​​ turn-based stochastic games. The​​​‌ Blackwell threshold is the‌ value of the discount‌​‌ factor above which optimal​​ policies become independent of​​​‌ the discount factor, meaning‌ that the players become‌​‌ perfectly farsighted. The sensitive​​ thresholds arise when interpolating​​​‌ between the mean-payoff objective‌ and the vanishing discount‌​‌ objective. Our bounds are​​ based on separation results​​​‌ for algebraic numbers.

8.1.5‌ Polyhedral methods in stochastic‌​‌ programming

Participants: Stéphane Gaubert​​, Jonathan Hornewall.​​​‌

The PhD thesis of‌ Jonathan Hornewall, in collaboration‌​‌ with CERMICS, ENPC, deals​​ with polyhedral methods in​​​‌ stochastic programmming. The article‌ 97 introduces a decision-focused‌​‌ scenario generation method for​​ contextual two-stage stochastic linear​​​‌ programs.

8.2 Non-linear Perron-Frobenius‌ theory, nonexpansive mappings and‌​‌ metric geometry

8.2.1 Characterising​​ JB-algebras using order reversing​​​‌ maps

Participants: Cormac Walsh‌.

We have been‌​‌ studying non-linear operators on​​ open cones, in particular​​​‌ ones that reverse the‌ order structure associated to‌​‌ the cone. A bijective​​ map that reverses the​​​‌ order in both directions‌ is called an order‌​‌ antimorphism. These are closely​​ related to the isometries​​​‌ of the Hilbert and‌ Thompson metrics on the‌​‌ cone.

An example of​​ an antimorphism on a​​​‌ cone is the inverse‌ map xx‌​‌-1 in the​​ positive cone of a​​​‌ JB-algebra. In fact, it‌ was conjectured by Lemmens‌​‌ and van Gaans that​​ these are the only​​​‌ examples. More precisely, they‌ conjectured that the existence‌​‌ of an order antimorphism​​ that is homogeneous of​​​‌ degree -1 on‌ the open cone of‌​‌ a order unit space​​ implies that the cone​​​‌ is the positive cone‌ of a JB-algebra.

In‌​‌ previous work  130,​​ 131, we established​​​‌ an even stronger result‌ in the finite dimensional‌​‌ case, where the map​​ was not assumed to​​​‌ be homogeneous. Recently, Roelands‌ and Tiersma have released‌​‌ a preprint where they​​ prove the conjecture in​​​‌ infinite dimension. We have‌ been working on extending‌​‌ our stronger result, where​​ there is no assumption​​​‌ of homogeneity, to the‌ infinite dimensional case.

8.2.2‌​‌ Invariant Finsler metrics on​​ symmetric spaces

Participants: Cormac​​​‌ Walsh.

This is‌ joint work with Bas‌​‌ Lemmens (Kent).

We are​​ interested in metrics on​​​‌ symmetric spaces, in particular‌ Finsler metrics that are‌​‌ invariant under the symmetries​​ of the space. In​​​‌ a previous paper 93‌, it was established‌​‌ that there is such​​ a metric naturally associated​​​‌ to every representation of‌ the symmetric space, which‌​‌ depends on the system​​​‌ of weights of the​ representation. More precisely, one​‌ takes the convex hull​​ of the weights and​​​‌ interprets that as the​ dual ball in the​‌ Artin subspace. The lengths​​ of all other vectors​​​‌ can then determined by​ invariance. We are investigating​‌ this correspondence between representations​​ and metrics in more​​​‌ detail. We wish to​ answer the question, concretely,​‌ which known representations correspond​​ to which invariant Finsler​​​‌ metrics?

We have also​ been looking more closely​‌ an especially interesting class​​ of symmetric space: the​​​‌ bounded symmetric domains with​ their Carathéodory (or equivalently,​‌ Kobayashi) metric. Here, the​​ metric restricts to the​​​‌ supremum norm on the​ Artin subspace. These symmetric​‌ spaces are particularly tractable​​ due to their relation​​​‌ with JB*-triples—each one arises​ as the unit ball​‌ of such a triple.​​ The algebraic structure of​​​‌ the triple turns out​ to be very helpful.​‌

We have been studying​​ how these spaces can​​​‌ be embedded in each​ other isometrically. We show​‌ 102 that a bounded​​ symmetric domain cannot be​​​‌ isometrically embedded into one​ of lower rank. In​‌ the case where the​​ rank of the target​​​‌ space is strictly larger,​ it turns out that​‌ there is a lot​​ of flexibility in what​​​‌ the map can look​ like. When the two​‌ spaces have the same​​ rank, however, the situation​​​‌ is much more rigid—we​ show that the map​‌ must respect any product​​ structure of the domain,​​​‌ and furthermore, in the​ case where the domain​‌ is irreducible, that the​​ map is either holomorphic​​​‌ or anti-holomorphic.

These results​ generalise work of Seo​‌ and Kim, who were​​ working under the additional​​​‌ assumption that the maps​ in question are C​‌1-smooth. They made​​ this assumption because they​​​‌ were using techniques from​ differential geometry, which require​‌ it. We are able​​ to relax the assumption​​​‌ because, rather than the​ small scale geometry of​‌ the space, we consider​​ the large scale geometry.​​​‌ In particular, a tool​ we use is the​‌ horofunction boundary—for bounded symmetric​​ domains, this was determined​​​‌ in earlier work by​ Chu–Cueto-Avellaneda—Lemmens.

8.2.3 Isoperimetry in​‌ Hilbert geometries

Participants: Amanda​​ Bigel, Stéphane Gaubert​​​‌, Constantin Vernicos,​ Cormac Walsh.

The​‌ PhD work of Amanda​​ Bigel deals with the​​​‌ investigation of isoperimetric inequalities​ in the geometries of​‌ Funk, Thompson, and Hilbert's​​ metric on convex domains.​​​‌ In particular, a characterization​ of the isoperimetrix with​‌ respect to the Thompson​​ metric of the Lorentz​​​‌ cone has been obtained.​

8.2.4 Horocyclic products

Participants:​‌ Luca Froger, Constantin​​ Vernicos, Cormac Walsh​​​‌.

This is the​ PhD work of Luca​‌ Froger. We are studying​​ horocyclic products of metric​​​‌ spaces, in particular, group​ actions on these spaces.​‌ One question we are​​ interested in answering is​​​‌ under what conditions is​ there a group making​‌ these horospherical products divisible​​ in the sense of​​​‌ Benoist? We are also​ interested in knowing when​‌ a horospherical product is​​ amenable. Here, amenability is​​​‌ to be understood in​ the purely metric sense,​‌ using Følner sets, not​​ the group theoretic notion.​​

8.2.5 External representation of​​​‌ hyperconvex sets

Participants: Stéphane‌ Gaubert.

MA: j'ai‌​‌ enleve “subsets of ℝ​​n” car cela​​​‌ fait une “erreur” dans‌ radar, il ecrit “Package‌​‌ hyperref Warning: Token not​​ allowed in a PDF​​​‌ string (Unicode): removing `math‌ shift' on input line‌​‌ 478.” meme avec protect​​ Hyperconvex spaces are another​​​‌ name for injective metric‌ spaces or tight-spans. In‌​‌ a current work with​​ Gleb Koshevoy, we are​​​‌ studying hyperconvex subsets of‌ n, equipped‌​‌ with the sup-norm. We​​ provide an external representation​​​‌ of hyperconvex sets, as‌ the intersection of a‌​‌ family of non-linear half-spaces​​ associated to norm-like functionals.​​​‌

8.3 Tropical algebra and‌ convex geometry

8.3.1 Formalizing‌​‌ convex polyhedra in Coq​​

Participants: Xavier Allamigeon,​​​‌ Quentin Canu.

In‌ a joint work with‌​‌ Pierre-Yves Strub (Meta), we​​ have achieved the formal​​​‌ verification of a counterexample‌ of Santos et al.‌​‌ to the so-called Hirsch​​ Conjecture on the diameter​​​‌ of polytopes. In contrast‌ with the pen-and-paper proof,‌​‌ our approach is entirely​​ computational: we implement in​​​‌ Coq and prove correct‌ an algorithm that explicitly‌​‌ computes, within the proof​​ assistant, vertex-edge graphs of​​​‌ polytopes as well as‌ their diameter. The originality‌​‌ of this certificate-based algorithm​​ is to achieve a​​​‌ tradeoff between simplicity and‌ efficiency. Simplicity is crucial‌​‌ in obtaining the proof​​ of correctness of the​​​‌ algorithm. This proof splits‌ into the correctness of‌​‌ an abstract algorithm stated​​ over proof-oriented data types​​​‌ and the correspondence with‌ a low-level implementation over‌​‌ computation-oriented data types. A​​ special effort has been​​​‌ made to reduce the‌ algorithm to a small‌​‌ sequence of elementary operations​​ (e.g., matrix multiplications, basic​​​‌ routines on sets and‌ graphs), in order to‌​‌ make the derivation of​​ the correctness of the​​​‌ low-level implementation more transparent.‌ Efficiency allows us to‌​‌ scale up to polytopes​​ with a challenging combinatorics.​​​‌ For instance, we formally‌ check the two counterexamples‌​‌ of Matschke, Santos and​​ Weibel to the Hirsch​​​‌ conjecture, respectively 20- and‌ 23-dimensional polytopes with 36‌​‌ 425 and 73 224​​ vertices involving rational coefficients​​​‌ with up to 40‌ digits in their numerator‌​‌ and denominator. We also​​ illustrate the performance of​​​‌ the method by computing‌ the list of vertices‌​‌ or the diameter of​​ well-known classes of polytopes,​​​‌ such as (polars of)‌ cyclic polytopes involved in‌​‌ McMullen's Upper Bound Theorem.​​ This work has appeared​​​‌ in the proceedings of‌ the conference CPP'23 58‌​‌.

Dealing with polyhedra​​ and their faces raises​​​‌ the problem of formalizing‌ order structures. We study‌​‌ this problem in a​​ joint work 57 with​​​‌ Cyril Cohen (Inria), Kazuhiko‌ Sakaguchi (Inria) and Pierre-Yves‌​‌ Strub (Meta). More precisely,​​ using order structures in​​​‌ a proof assistant naturally‌ raises the problem of‌​‌ working with multiple instances​​ of a same structure​​​‌ over a common type‌ of elements. This goes‌​‌ against the main design​​ pattern of hierarchies used​​​‌ for instance in Coq's‌ MathComp or Lean's mathlib‌​‌ libraries, where types are​​ canonically associated to at​​​‌ most one instance and‌ instances share a common‌​‌ overloaded syntax. We introduce​​​‌ new design patterns to​ leverage these issues, and​‌ apply them to the​​ formalization of order structures​​​‌ in the MathComp library.​ A common idea in​‌ these patterns is underloading,​​ i.e., a disambiguation of​​​‌ operators on a common​ type. In addition, our​‌ design patterns include a​​ way to deal with​​​‌ duality in order structures​ in a convenient way.​‌ We hence formalize a​​ large hierarchy which includes​​​‌ partial orders, semilattices, lattices​ as well as many​‌ variants. We finally pay​​ a special attention to​​​‌ order substructures. We introduce​ a new kind of​‌ structure called prelattice. They​​ are abstractions of semilattices,​​​‌ and allow us to​ deal with finite lattices​‌ and their sublattices within​​ a common signature. As​​​‌ an application, we report​ on significant simplifications of​‌ the formalization of the​​ face lattices of polyhedra​​​‌ in the Coq-Polyhedra library.​

8.3.2 Linear algebra over​‌ systems

Participants: Marianne Akian​​, Stéphane Gaubert.​​​‌

In a joint work​ with Louis Rowen (Univ.​‌ Bar Ilan), we study​​ the properties of “systems”.​​​‌ The latter provide a​ general setting encompassing extensions​‌ of the tropical semifields​​ and hyperfields. Moreover, they​​​‌ have the advantage to​ be well adapted to​‌ the study of linear​​ or polynomial equations. In​​​‌ particular, in 46,​ we characterize the semiring​‌ systems which arise from​​ hyperrings.

In 45,​​​‌ we are studying linear​ algebra properties over a​‌ generalization of “systems” called​​ “T-pairs”. We are still​​​‌ working on improvements of​ the results of 45​‌.

8.3.3 Roots over​​ the symmetrized tropical semiring​​​‌ and eigenvalues of tropical​ symmetric matrices

Participants: Marianne​‌ Akian, Stéphane Gaubert​​.

The tropical semifield​​​‌ can be thought of​ as the image of​‌ a field with a​​ non-archimedean valuation. It allows​​​‌ in this way to​ study the asymptotics of​‌ Puiseux series with complex​​ coefficients. When dealing with​​​‌ Puiseux series with real​ coefficients and with its​‌ associated order, it is​​ convenient to use the​​​‌ symmetrized tropical semiring introduced​ in 115 (see also​‌ 68), and the​​ signed valuation which associates​​​‌ to any series its​ valuation together with its​‌ sign.

In a work​​ 16 which started during​​​‌ the postdoc of Hanieh​ Tavakolipour (Amirkabir University of​‌ Technology) in the team,​​ we studied the roots's​​​‌ multiplicities and the factorization​ of polynomials over the​‌ symmetrized tropical semiring. We​​ then deduced a Descartes'​​​‌ rule of sign over​ ordered valued fields. This​‌ builds in particular on​​ 69 (for multiplicities) and​​​‌ on 65.

More​ recently, in a work​‌ with Dariush Kiani and​​ Hanieh Tavakolipour (Amirkabir University​​​‌ of Technology) 42,​ we studied with the​‌ above tools the asymptotics​​ of eigenvalues and eigenvectors​​​‌ of symmetric positive definite​ matrices over the field​‌ of Puiseux series. In​​ a more recent work,​​​‌ we are studying the​ eigenvalues of general symmetric​‌ matrices over the field​​ of Puiseux series and​​​‌ over the tropical semiring.​

8.3.4 Tropical Systems of​‌ Polynomial Equations

Participants: Marianne​​ Akian, Matías Bender​​​‌, Antoine Bereau,​ Stéphane Gaubert.

The​‌ PhD thesis of Antoine​​ Bereau 71 dealt with​​ systems of polynomial equations​​​‌ over tropical semifields. In‌ 38, 14,‌​‌ we established a Nullstellenstatz​​ for sparse tropical polynomial​​​‌ systems. We reduce a‌ polynomial system to a‌​‌ linearized system obtained by​​ an appropriate truncation of​​​‌ the Macaulay matrix. Our‌ approach is inspired by‌​‌ a construction of Canny-Emiris​​ (1993), refined by Sturmfels​​​‌ (1994). It leads to‌ an improved estimate of‌​‌ the truncation degree. We​​ also establish a tropical​​​‌ positivstellensatz, allowing one to‌ decide the containment of‌​‌ tropical basic semialgebraic sets.​​ This method leads to​​​‌ the solution of systems‌ of tropical linear equalities‌​‌ and inequalities, which reduces​​ to mean payoff games​​​‌ 37, 14.‌

Building on this construction,‌​‌ in collaboration with Yue​​ Ren (University of Durham,​​​‌ UK), we are investigating‌ new efficient methods for‌​‌ computing resultants and solving​​ structured polynomial systems. These​​​‌ systems include cases where‌ the degeneration into tropical‌​‌ forms, such as vertically​​ and horizontally parameterized systems,​​​‌ is well understood 96‌.

8.3.5 Systems of‌​‌ sparse polynomial equations and​​ convex polytopes

Participants: Matías​​​‌ Bender.

Polynomial systems‌ are ubiquitous in applications.‌​‌ They allow us to​​ model problems involving curved​​​‌ objects without linearizing them.‌ Dealing with polynomials is‌​‌ challenging, as worst-case bounds​​ are double exponential. However,​​​‌ the polynomials that we‌ encounter in practice are‌​‌ structured, and so these​​ bounds are too pessimistic.​​​‌ Nevertheless, our computational strategies,‌ designed to deal with‌​‌ arbitrary systems, cannot be​​ applied successfully to these​​​‌ systems, as they do‌ not exploit the structure‌​‌ of the problems that​​ we encounter. For this​​​‌ reason, it is central‌ to develop algorithms that‌​‌ can take these structures​​ into account. Among them,​​​‌ one of the most‌ common structures is sparsity,‌​‌ that is, the polynomials​​ that we encounter can​​​‌ be written as a‌ linear combination of a‌​‌ few monomials. Toric and​​ tropical geometry give us​​​‌ a way of understanding‌ and exploiting sparsity.

As‌​‌ part of the PhD​​ project of Charles Checa​​​‌ (now a postdoc at‌ U. Copenhagen, Denmark), together‌​‌ with Laurent Busé (Team​​ Aromath, Inria Sophia-Antipolis) and​​​‌ Elias Tsigaridas (Team Ouragan,‌ Inria Paris), we focus‌​‌ on multihomogeneous systems, which​​ are sparse polynomials with​​​‌ simple but ubiquitous sparsity‌ structure. By extending the‌​‌ seminal work of Bayer​​ and Stillman, in 20​​​‌, we show the‌ first relation between the‌​‌ complexity of computing Gröbner​​ bases for these systems​​​‌ and the multigraded Castelnuovo-Mumford‌ regularity introduced by Maclagan‌​‌ and Smith. Moreover, we​​ study specialized algorithms to​​​‌ compute projections of the‌ zero set of these‌​‌ varieties, when they are​​ finite, establishing a new​​​‌ relation between multiplication maps‌ and higher-dimensional varieties, and‌​‌ via them, new complexity​​ bounds to solve these​​​‌ problems 27.

8.4‌ Tropical methods applied to‌​‌ optimization, perturbation theory and​​ matrix analysis

8.4.1 Tropicalization​​​‌ of interior point methods‌ and application to complexity‌​‌

Participants: Xavier Allamigeon,​​ Stéphane Gaubert.

It​​​‌ is an open question‌ to determine if the‌​‌ theory of self-concordant barriers​​ can provide an interior​​​‌ point method with strongly‌ polynomial complexity in linear‌​‌ programming. In the special​​​‌ case of the logarithmic​ barrier, it was shown​‌ in 51,6​​ that the answer is​​​‌ negative.

In a subsequent​ work 50 with Abdellah​‌ Aznag (Columbia University) and​​ Yassine Hamdi (Ecole Polytechnique),​​​‌ we have studied the​ tropicalization of the central​‌ path associated with the​​ entropic barrier studied by​​​‌ Bubeck and Eldan (Proc.​ Mach. Learn. Research, 2015),​‌ i.e., the logarithmic limit​​ of this central path​​​‌ for a parametric family​ of linear programs defined​‌ over the field of​​ Puiseux series. Our main​​​‌ result is that the​ tropicalization of the entropic​‌ central path is a​​ piecewise linear curve which​​​‌ coincides with the tropicalization​ of the logarithmic central​‌ path studied by Allamigeon​​ et al. in 51​​​‌,6.

In​ the work 66,​‌ we have now shown​​ that none of the​​​‌ self-concordant barrier interior point​ methods is strongly polynomial.​‌ This result is obtained​​ by establishing that, on​​​‌ parametric families of convex​ optimization problems, the log-limit​‌ of the central path​​ degenerates to the same​​​‌ piecewise linear curve, independently​ of the choice of​‌ the barrier function. We​​ also provided an improved​​​‌ counter example, with an​ explicit linear program that​‌ falls in the same​​ class as the Klee–Minty​​​‌ counterexample, i.e., a​ n-dimensional combinatorial cube,​‌ in which the number​​ of iterations is 2​​​‌n.

A key​ tool in this work​‌ consists of metric inequalities,​​ controlling the convergence of​​​‌ the log-images of semialgebraic​ sets to a polyhedral​‌ complex (their tropicalization). Explicit​​ convergence bounds have been​​​‌ subsequently established, see §​8.4.4 below. These results​‌ were presented in the​​ Phd thesis of Nicolas​​​‌ Vandame 128.

In​ a joint work 60​‌, 17 with Daniel​​ Dadush, Georg Loho, Bento​​​‌ Natura and László Végh,​ we establish a natural​‌ connection between the complexity​​ of interior point methods​​​‌ and that of the​ simplex method, and deduce​‌ combinatorial bounds on the​​ number of iterations. In​​​‌ more details, we introduce​ a new polynomial-time path-following​‌ interior point method where​​ the number of iterations​​​‌ also admits a combinatorial​ upper bound O(​‌2nn1​​.5logn​​​‌) for an n​-variable linear program in​‌ standard form. The number​​ of iterations of our​​​‌ algorithm is at most​ O(n1​‌.5logn​​) times the number​​​‌ of segments of any​ piecewise linear curve in​‌ the wide neighborhood of​​ the central path. In​​​‌ particular, it matches the​ number of iterations of​‌ any path following interior​​ point method up to​​​‌ this polynomial factor. The​ overall exponential upper bound​‌ derives from studying the​​ `max central path', a​​​‌ piecewise-linear curve with the​ number of pieces bounded​‌ by the total length​​ of 2n shadow​​​‌ vertex simplex paths.

8.4.2​ Tropical Nash equilibria and​‌ complementarity problems over oriented​​ matroids

Participants: Xavier Allamigeon​​​‌, Stéphane Gaubert.​

Linear complementarity programming is​‌ a generalization of linear​​ programming which encompasses the​​​‌ computation of Nash equilibria​ for bimatrix games. While​‌ the latter problem is​​ PPAD-complete, we show in​​ 63 that the analogue​​​‌ of this problem in‌ tropical algebra can be‌​‌ solved in polynomial time.​​ Moreover, we prove that​​​‌ the Lemke–Howson algorithm carries‌ over the tropical setting‌​‌ and performs a linear​​ number of pivots in​​​‌ the worst case. A‌ consequence of this result‌​‌ is a new class​​ of (classical) bimatrix games​​​‌ for which Nash equilibria‌ computation can be done‌​‌ in polynomial time. This​​ is joint work with​​​‌ Frédéric Meunier (Cermics, ENPC).‌ Current work focuses on‌​‌ abstracting the notion of​​ Nash equilibra over oriented​​​‌ matroids and showing that‌ the problem of finding‌​‌ such an equilibria is​​ still in PPAD (modulo​​​‌ chirotope oracles). This is‌ joint work with Frédéric‌​‌ Meunier (ENPC).

8.4.3 Signed​​ Tropicalization of Polars and​​​‌ application to Matrix Cones‌

Participants: Marianne Akian,‌​‌ Xavier Allamigeon, Stéphane​​ Gaubert.

With Sergey​​​‌ Sergeev (U. Birmingham), we‌ study in 13 the‌​‌ tropical analogue of the​​ notion of polar of​​​‌ a cone over the‌ symmetrized tropical semiring (see‌​‌ for instance 115,​​ 68). We characterize​​​‌ in particular the tropical‌ polars of sets of‌​‌ nonnegative tropical vectors, and​​ relate them with images​​​‌ by the nonarchimedean valuation‌ of classical polars over‌​‌ real closed nonarchimedean fields.​​ We study in particular​​​‌ cones of matrices, and‌ optimization problems.

8.4.4 Log-limits‌​‌ of semi-algebraic sets

Participants:​​ Xavier Allamigeon, Stéphane​​​‌ Gaubert.

We study‌ the log-convergence of parametric‌​‌ families of semialgebraic sets​​ to their valuation. We​​​‌ obtain explicit metric estimates‌ under genericity conditions for‌​‌ basic semialgebraic sets. In​​ the general case, we​​​‌ establish a multivariate extension‌ of the Denef–Pas cell‌​‌ decomposition. Using Smale’s α​​-theory, we give a​​​‌ quantitative version of this‌ decomposition that allows us‌​‌ to prove a metric​​ lifting theorem for semialgebraic​​​‌ sets. It yields a‌ constructive bound on the‌​‌ one-sided Hausdorff convergence of​​ the parametric family to​​​‌ its valuation. These results‌ were presented in the‌​‌ PhD thesis of Nicolas​​ Vandame 128, we​​​‌ are pursuing the work‌ on this topic.SG: kept‌​‌ the para as it​​ is ongoing, ok?

8.5​​​‌ Relu and softplus neural‌ nets as zero-sum turn-based‌​‌ games

Participants: Stéphane Gaubert​​.

In a joint​​​‌ work with Yannis Vlassopoulos‌ (Athena research center) 89‌​‌, we show that​​ the output of a​​​‌ ReLU neural network can‌ be interpreted as the‌​‌ value of a zero-sum,​​ turn-based, stopping game, which​​​‌ we call the ReLU‌ net game. The game‌​‌ runs in the direction​​ opposite to that of​​​‌ the network, and the‌ input of the network‌​‌ serves as the terminal​​ reward of the game.​​​‌ In fact, evaluating the‌ network is the same‌​‌ as running the Shapley-Bellman​​ backward recursion for the​​​‌ value of the game.‌ Using the expression of‌​‌ the value of the​​ game as an expected​​​‌ total payoff with respect‌ to the path measure‌​‌ induced by the transition​​ probabilities and a pair​​​‌ of optimal policies, we‌ derive a discrete Feynman-Kac-type‌​‌ path-integral formula for the​​ network output. This game-theoretic​​​‌ representation can be used‌ to derive bounds on‌​‌ the output from bounds​​​‌ on the input, leveraging​ the monotonicity of Shapley​‌ operators, and to verify​​ robustness properties using policies​​​‌ as certificates. Moreover, training​ the neural network becomes​‌ an inverse game problem:​​ given pairs of terminal​​​‌ rewards and corresponding values,​ one seeks transition probabilities​‌ and rewards of a​​ game that reproduces them.​​​‌ Finally, we show that​ a similar approach applies​‌ to neural networks with​​ Softplus activation functions, where​​​‌ the ReLU net game​ is replaced by its​‌ entropic regularization.

8.6 Polynomial​​ optimization and certificates of​​​‌ positivity

Participants: Matías Bender​.

As part of​‌ the PhD project of​​ Chaoping Zhu (co-advised by​​​‌ Matías Bender and Elias​ Tsigaridas, IMJ-PRG, Paris), we​‌ studied algorithms to compute​​ certificates of non-negativity for​​​‌ polynomials. These certificates are​ algebraic identities that allow​‌ us to prove that​​ a polynomial is non-negative​​​‌ over the reals, and​ arise, for example, in​‌ unconstrained optimization. In the​​ univariate setting, this problem​​​‌ can be solved using​ sum of squares decomposition.​‌ Together with P. di​​ Dio from U. Konstanz,​​​‌ Germany, in 32,​ we improve the work​‌ of Chevillard, Harrison, Joldes,​​ and Lauter to obtain​​​‌ a cubic-complexity algorithm to​ compute such a sum​‌ of squares decomposition. Moreover,​​ we relate the sum​​​‌ of squares decomposition with​ other certificates, such as​‌ the ones studied by​​ Karlin. We also consider​​​‌ the multivariate case. In​ this setting, as shown​‌ by Artin, we can​​ perform our certification by​​​‌ writing the polynomial as​ a sum of rational​‌ functions, but the best​​ known bounds for these​​​‌ polynomials, proved by Lombardi,​ Perrucci, and Roy, involve​‌ a tower of five​​ exponentials. Following previous work​​​‌ by Parrillo, Nie, Demmel,​ and Sturmfels, an alternative​‌ certificate exists by writing​​ the polynomial as a​​​‌ sum of squares modulo​ its gradient ideal. In​‌ 34, we follow​​ this approach and present​​​‌ a single-exponential algorithm that​ can certify the non-negativity​‌ of polynomials that satisfy​​ two assumptions: their minimum​​​‌ is attained, and their​ gradient variety is zero-dimensional.​‌ In a subsequent paper​​ with K. Kozhasov (Université​​​‌ Côte d'Azur) 33,​ we extend these ideas​‌ to arbitrary polynomials by​​ using perturbations to reduce​​​‌ our certification to the​ previous special case. In​‌ this way, we obtain​​ the first single-exponential bounds​​​‌ to solve this problem.​

8.7 Applications

8.7.1 Performance​‌ evaluation of emergency call​​ centers and emergency services​​​‌

Participants: Xavier Allamigeon,​ Pascal Capetillo, Stéphane​‌ Gaubert, Guillaume Thomas​​.

Since 2014, we​​​‌ have been collaborating with​ Préfecture de Police (Régis​‌ Reboul and LcL Stéphane​​ Raclot), more specifically with​​​‌ Brigade de Sapeurs de​ Pompiers de Paris (BSPP)​‌ and Direction de Sécurité​​ de Proximité de l'agglomération​​​‌ parisienne (DSPAP), on the​ performance evaluation of the​‌ new organization (PFAU, “Plate​​ forme d'appels d'urgence”) to​​​‌ handle emergency calls to​ firemen and policemen in​‌ the Paris area. We​​ developed analytical models, based​​​‌ on Petri nets with​ priorities, and fluid limits,​‌ see 53, 54​​, 72. In​​​‌ 2019, with four students​ of École polytechnique, Céline​‌ Moucer, Julia Escribe, Skandère​​ Sahli and Alban Zammit,​​ we performed case studies,​​​‌ showing the improvement brought‌ by the two level‌​‌ filtering procedure.

Moreover, in​​ 2019, this work has​​​‌ been extended to encompass‌ the handling of health‌​‌ emergency calls, with a​​ new collaboration, involving responsibles​​​‌ from the four services‌ of medical emergency aid‌​‌ of Assistance Publique –​​ Hôpitaux de Paris (AP-HP),​​​‌ i.e., with SAMU75, 92,‌ 93, 94, in the‌​‌ framework of a project​​ coordinated by Dr. Christophe​​​‌ Leroy from AP-HP. As‌ part of his PhD‌​‌ work, Marin Boyet have​​ developed Petri net models​​​‌ capturing the characteristic of‌ the centers (CRRA) handling‌​‌ emergency calls the SAMU,​​ in order to make​​​‌ dimensioning recommendations. Following this,‌ we have been strongly‌​‌ solicited by AP-HP during​​ the pandemic of Covid-19​​​‌ in order to determine‌ crisis dimensioning of SAMU.‌​‌

In parallel, we have​​ further investigated the theoretical​​​‌ properties of timed Petri‌ nets with preselection and‌​‌ priority routing. We represent​​ the behavior of these​​​‌ systems by piecewise affine‌ dynamical systems. We use‌​‌ tools from the theory​​ of nonexpansive mappings to​​​‌ analyze these systems. We‌ establish an equivalence theorem‌​‌ between priority-free fluid timed​​ Petri nets and semi-Markov​​​‌ decision processes, from which‌ we derive the convergence‌​‌ to a periodic regime​​ and the polynomial-time computability​​​‌ of the throughput. More‌ generally, we develop an‌​‌ approach inspired by tropical​​ geometry, characterizing the congestion​​​‌ phases as the cells‌ of a polyhedral complex.‌​‌ These results are illustrated​​ by the application to​​​‌ the performance evaluation of‌ emergency call centers of‌​‌ SAMU in the Paris​​ area. These results have​​​‌ been published in 56‌.

In 55,‌​‌ we provided explicit formulæ​​ allowing one to compute​​​‌ the time needed by‌ a call center to‌​‌ return to a stationary​​ state after a bulk​​​‌ of calls. This is‌ based on a turnpike-type‌​‌ theorem for Markov decision​​ processes.

These results were​​​‌ also presented in the‌ Phd thesis 74.‌​‌

In the followup work​​ described below (Section 8.7.2​​​‌), in the framework‌ of the URGE project‌​‌ (see Section 10.3.3 below)​​ we are extending these​​​‌ models in order to‌ evaluate the dimensioning of‌​‌ emergency departments. This is​​ the object of the​​​‌ PhD work of Pascal‌ Capetillo, which started in‌​‌ Nov. 2023.

8.7.2 Stationary​​ regimes of piecewise linear​​​‌ dynamical systems with priorities‌

Participants: Xavier Allamigeon,‌​‌ Pascal Capetillo, Stéphane​​ Gaubert.

A key​​​‌ question in the study‌ of Petri nets with‌​‌ priority is the existence​​ of stationary regimes. (See​​​‌ section above for motivations.)‌ The counter equations of‌​‌ these Petri nets, modelling​​ the evolution of events,​​​‌ follow piecewise linear equations‌ that are similar to‌​‌ the dynamic programming equations​​ of semi-Markov decision processes,​​​‌ up to a key‌ new feature: the “probabilities'‌​‌ can take negative values​​ – which entails that​​​‌ the dynamics is no-longer‌ monotone. Although stationary regimes‌​‌ were found (by a​​ case by case analysis)​​​‌ for a number of‌ concrete models, including emergency‌​‌ call centers, it has​​ been an open problem​​​‌ to show that these‌ regimes do exist under‌​‌ general circumstances. Using techniques​​​‌ of topological degree theory,​ we show in 59​‌ that stationary regimes do​​ exist, independently of the​​​‌ choice of resources, for​ a broad enough class​‌ of systems (including all​​ known examples). This result​​​‌ also extends Kohlberg's theorem​ (existence of invariant half-lines​‌ for nonexpansive piecewise affine​​ maps), relaxing the nonexpansiveness​​​‌ assumption. In the followup​ work 25, we​‌ showed how to enumerate​​ the stationary regimes, in​​​‌ order to compute a​ phase diagram, showing the​‌ different bottleneck regimes, depending​​ on the allocation of​​​‌ resources. SG: updated

8.7.3​ Optimal pricing of energy​‌ contracts

Participants: Abdellah Bulaich​​, Stéphane Gaubert.​​​‌

This work on optimal​ pricing of electricity contracts​‌ is carried out within​​ the “Defi EDF Inria”,​​​‌ with a collaboration between​ Wim van Ackooij, Luce​‌ Brotcorne (Inria Lille) and​​ S. Gaubert, leading to​​​‌ the hiring in Cifre​ PhD of Abdellah Bulaich-Mehamdi.​‌ We investigated the problem​​ of design of a​​​‌ menu of contracts of​ a prescribed cardinality, in​‌ particular, we related its​​ formulation in terms of​​​‌ the best approximation of​ a convex function by​‌ a polyhedral function with​​ a prescribed number of​​​‌ facets to the problem​ of optimal quantization of​‌ probability measures, using methods​​ from optimal transport 29​​​‌

8.7.4 Aggregated models of​ flexibilities in long term​‌ investment models

Participants: Stéphane​​ Gaubert.

Within the​​​‌ framework of the “Defi​ EDF Inria”, we started​‌ a joint project with​​ the Polaris team of​​​‌ Inria Rhône-Alpes (Bruno Gaujal​ and Nicolas Gast) and​‌ with Olivier Beaude and​​ Juliette Lesturgie, from EDF​​​‌ Labs, on the development​ of aggregated models of​‌ flexibilities of customers in​​ the electricity field. Examples​​​‌ of flexibilities are given​ by parks of electric​‌ vehicles, or hydroelectric resources.​​ These aggregated models are​​​‌ used to optimize long​ term investments. This is​‌ the object of the​​ PhD thesis of Hélène​​​‌ Arvis, jointly supervised with​ Polaris. We showed in​‌ 31 that flexibilities of​​ electric vehicles can be​​​‌ aggregated exactly using generalized​ polymatroids, allowing us to​‌ use submodular optimization techniques​​ to optimize the production​​​‌ of energy, leveraging flexibilities.​

8.7.5 Simulation and optimization​‌ of robust strategies for​​ spectrum auctions

Participants: Marianne​​​‌ Akian, Stéphane Gaubert​, Jad Zeroual.​‌

In order to deploy​​ new 5G mobile networks,​​​‌ telecommunication operators must acquire​ new frequency bands (called​‌ spectrum). The acquisition of​​ these frequencies is done,​​​‌ in each country, through​ participation in auctions whose​‌ rules are specific and​​ dictated by the licences’​​​‌ owners (usually states). The​ aim of the PhD​‌ thesis of Jad Zeroual,​​ supervised by Marianne Akian,​​​‌ Stéphane Gaubert, Aurélien Bechler​ (Orange Labs) and Mathieu​‌ Chardy (Orange Labs), is​​ to develop mathematical models​​​‌ allowing one to facilitate​ the understanding and participation​‌ in licensed spectrum auctions,​​ and in particular to​​​‌ compute optimal acquisition strategies​ of the desired amount​‌ of spectrum.

In a​​ first work 30,​​​‌ we studied a model​ of auction representative of​‌ the 5G auction in​​ France. We determine the​​​‌ optimal strategy of a​ bidder, assuming that the​‌ valuations of competitors are​​ unknown to this bidder​​ and that competitors adopt​​​‌ the straightforward bidding strategy.‌ The model is based‌​‌ on a Partially Observable​​ Markov Decision Process (POMDP).​​​‌ We show, under some‌ assumptions on the probability‌​‌ distributions of the valuations​​ of the competitors, that​​​‌ this POMDP admits a‌ concise statistics, avoiding the‌​‌ solution of a dynamic​​ programming equation in the​​​‌ space of beliefs. The‌ results are also illustrated‌​‌ by numerical experiments, comparing​​ the value of the​​​‌ bidder with the value‌ of a perfectly informed‌​‌ one. The paper 30​​ obtained the best paper​​​‌ award at the conference‌ NETGCOOP'2024, an extended version‌​‌ is now published in​​ 23.

In a​​​‌ followup work 36,‌ we studied multidimensional simple‌​‌ clock options. When the​​ opponents' valuations satisfy the​​​‌ ordinary substitutes condition, we‌ show that it is‌​‌ optimal to bid on​​ a fixed lot overtime.​​​‌ In this setting, we‌ consider a continuous-time version‌​‌ of the SCA auction​​ in which the prices​​​‌ follow a differential inclusion‌ with a piecewise-constant dynamics.‌​‌ We show that there​​ exists a unique solution​​​‌ in the sense of‌ Filippov. This guarantees that‌​‌ the continuous-time model coincides​​ with the limit of​​​‌ the discrete-time auction when‌ price increments tend to‌​‌ zero. Moreover, we showed​​ that the value function​​​‌ of this limit auction‌ is piecewise linear (though‌​‌ possibly discontinuous). We illustrated​​ these results by analyzing​​​‌ a simplified version of‌ the multiband Australian spectrum‌​‌ auction of 2017.

In​​ an ongoing work in​​​‌ collaboration with Guido Schäfer‌ (CWI), we are studying‌​‌ the consistency and robustness​​ of strategies in Simple​​​‌ Clock Auctions, tooking inspiration‌ from 92, while‌​‌ adapting the model to​​ fit spectrum auctions. This​​​‌ work aims to provide‌ guarantees on the robustness‌​‌ of strategies such as​​ the Straightforward Bidding and​​​‌ to device robust strategies‌ with the help of‌​‌ a black-box prediction tool​​ such as experts’ advice​​​‌ or Machine Learning predictions.‌

9 Bilateral contracts and‌​‌ grants with industry

9.1​​ Bilateral contracts with industry​​​‌

Participants: Marianne Akian,‌ Stéphane Gaubert, Abdellah‌​‌ Bulaich Mehamdi, Jad​​ Zeroual.

  • Simulation and​​​‌ optimization of robust strategies‌ for spectrum auctions.‌​‌ Collaboration of Marianne Akian​​ and Stéphane Gaubert with​​​‌ Aurélien Bechler and Mathieu‌ Chardy from Orange Labs,‌​‌ for the supervision of​​ the Phd work of​​​‌ Jad Zeroual (CIFRE PhD‌ from January 9, 2024,‌​‌ directed by Marianne Akian).​​
  • Optimal pricing of energy​​​‌ contracts. Collaboration of‌ Stéphane Gaubert with Luce‌​‌ Brotcorne (Inria Lille, INOCS​​ team), Wim Van Ackooij​​​‌ and Quentin Jacquet, from‌ EDF Labs. This is‌​‌ part of the “DEFI​​ EDF-inria”. This supports the​​​‌ CIFRE Phd Thesis of‌ Adbellah Bulaich-Mehamdi.
  • Aggregated models‌​‌ of flexibilities in long​​ term investment models.​​​‌ Collaboration of Stéphane Gaubert‌ with Bruno Gaujal and‌​‌ Nicolas Gast (Inria Rhône-Alpes,​​ Polaris team) and Olivier​​​‌ Beaude and Juliette Lesturgie,‌ from EDF Labs. This‌​‌ is part of the​​ “DEFI EDF-inria”. This supports​​​‌ the CIFRE Phd Thesis‌ of Hélène Arvis.

10‌​‌ Partnerships and cooperations

10.1​​ International initiatives

10.1.1 Inria​​​‌ associate team not involved‌ in an IIL or‌​‌ an international program

TropOptim​​​‌
  • Title:
    Tropical Algorithms for​ Optimization
  • Duration:
    2025 ->​‌ 2028
  • Coordinator:
    Daniel Dadush​​ (dadush@cwi.nl)
  • Partners:
    • CWI Amsterdam​​​‌ (Pays-Bas)
  • Inria contact:
    Xavier​ Allamigeon
  • Summary:

    The objective​‌ of the project is​​ to make progress on​​​‌ several problems in optimization​ and game theory (complexity​‌ of linear programming, semidefinite​​ programming, mean payoff games,​​​‌ auction theory and mechanism​ design) by exploiting their​‌ connection with tropical geometry.​​ To this extent, the​​​‌ associate team federates the​ "Network & Optimization" team​‌ from CWI which has​​ an extensive expertise in​​​‌ combinatorial and strongly polynomial​ algorithms for linear optimization,​‌ as well as in​​ mechanism design, and the​​​‌ Tropical team from Inria,​ which has pioneered the​‌ application of tropical geometry​​ to the complexity of​​​‌ convex optimization problems, mean​ payoff games, bilevel programming,​‌ and combinatorial auctions. The​​ associate team will facilitate​​​‌ the joint works between​ the two teams by​‌ funding the organization of​​ joint meetings and visits​​​‌ by permanent members and​ PhD students.

    A kickoff​‌ workshop of the team​​ took place at CWI​​​‌ in July 2025, followed​ by a visit of​‌ Jad Zeroual to CWI​​ at the fall, initiating​​​‌ a collaboration with Guido​ Schäfer on auction theory.​‌

10.1.2 Participation in other​​ International Programs

Since 2025,​​​‌ Matias Bender has been​ part of a two-year​‌ Franco-German visiting grant (Procope–Partenariat​​ Hubert Curien, PHC) between​​​‌ Sorbonne University (PI: Elias​ Tsigaridas) and Goethe University​‌ Frankfurt, Germany (PI: Thorsten​​ Theobald).

10.2 International research​​​‌ visitors

10.2.1 Visits of​ international scientists

Other international​‌ visits to the team​​
Gleb Koshevoy
  • Status
    Chief​​​‌ researcher
  • Institution of origin:​
    The Institute for Information​‌ Transmission Problems, Russian Academy​​ of Sciences (IITP RAS).​​​‌
  • Country:
    Russia.
  • Dates:
    February–April​ 2025
  • Context of the​‌ visit:
    Collaboration on hyperconvexity​​ and algebraic combinatorics.

10.2.2​​​‌ Visits to international teams​

Research stays abroad
Gaubert​‌ Stéphane
  • Visited institution:
    University​​ of Chicago
  • Country:
    USA​​​‌
  • Dates:
    July 3 –​ 7, 2025
  • Context of​‌ the visit:
    FACCTS -​​ France Chicago center project​​​‌ on tropical geometry applied​ to machine learning. Collaboration​‌ with Shmuel Friedland (University​​ of Illinois at Chicago)​​​‌ and Lek-Heng Lim (University​ of Chicago).

10.3 National​‌ initiatives

10.3.1 ANR

Participants:​​ Marianne Akian, Xavier​​​‌ Allamigeon, Cormac Walsh​, Stéphane Gaubert.​‌

  • ANR project HilbertXField (“Géométries​​ de Hilbert sur tout​​​‌ corps valué”). ANR leader:​ Antonin Guilloux. Partners: IMJ-PRG/OURAGAN​‌ (Sorbonne Université, pole leader​​ Antonin Guilloux), CMAP/TROPICAL (Inria,​​​‌ pole leader: Cormac Walsh),​ Institut Fourier (Grenoble, pole​‌ leader Anne Parreau).

Participants:​​ Marianne Akian, Xavier​​​‌ Allamigeon, Stéphane Gaubert​.

  • ANR project ZADyG​‌: Zoology of Algorithmic​​ Methods for Dynamic Games​​​‌ (ANR-25-CE48-7058, 4 years from​ January 2026). This is​‌ a collaborative research project​​ (PRC), the coordinator is​​​‌ Marianne Akian, and the​ poles/partners are LABRI (Université​‌ de Bordeaux) with pole​​ leader Nathanaël Fijalkow, and​​​‌ LACL (Université Paris-Est Créteil)​ with pole leader Youssouf​‌ Oualhadj.

    The aim of​​ the project is to​​​‌ develop a unified vision​ of approaches on complexity​‌ and algorithmic issues of​​ stochastic games. The ANR​​​‌ funding includes one PhD​ thesis (3 years) for​‌ the Inria Saclay team,​​ and 18 months of​​ Post-doc for each of​​​‌ the other partners. It‌ also includes the organization‌​‌ of joint meetings together​​ with an open conference.​​​‌

Participants: Matías Bender.‌

  • ANR project PeACE:‌​‌ Polynomials and applications via​​ efficient computations (ANR-25-CE48-3760; 226,000​​​‌ euros). This project is‌ funded by ANR as‌​‌ part of the program​​ JCJC (young researchers). Its​​​‌ PI is Matias Bender‌ and the project encompass‌​‌ collaborations with researchers in​​ Denmark, France, UK, and​​​‌ US, on topics as‌ sparse and structured polynomial‌​‌ systems and applications to​​ topological data analysis.

10.3.2​​​‌ Programme Gaspard Monge pour‌ l'optimisation, la recherche opérationnelle‌​‌ et leurs interactions avec​​ les sciences des données​​​‌

Participants: Matías Bender.‌

  • Since 2023, SOAP -‌​‌ Sparsity in Optimization via​​ Algebra and Polynomials, with​​​‌ Elias Tsigaridas (IMJ), project‌ funded by FMJH within‌​‌ the PGMO programme.

10.3.3​​ Joint INRIA & AP-HP​​​‌ Bernoulli lab project: “URGE”‌

  • The project URGE (Analyse‌​‌ des parcours patients aux​​ URgences et optimisation des​​​‌ prises en charGE), started‌ at the fall 2022,‌​‌ in the framework of​​ the joint Inria &​​​‌ AP-HP Bernoulli lab. The‌ goal of the project‌​‌ is to develop modelling,​​ simulation, performance analysis, and​​​‌ visualization tools, in order‌ to help physicians to‌​‌ optimize the staffing of​​ emergency services. This collaborative​​​‌ project, of four years,‌ involves the Tropical and‌​‌ Aviz teams from INRIA​​ Saclay, the Dyogene team​​​‌ from Inria Paris, and‌ the Fédération Hospitalo-Universitaire (FHU)‌​‌ / IMPEC Improving Emergency​​ Care, AP-HP / Sorbonne​​​‌ Université / Inserm. The‌ project is led by‌​‌ X. Allamigeon (Tropical) and​​ Y. Yordanov (AP-HP, Saint-Antoine)​​​‌ and involves P. Capetillo,‌ S. Gaubert (Tropical), Ch.‌​‌ Fricker (Dyogene), J.D. Fekete​​ (Aviz).

11 Dissemination

11.1​​​‌ Promoting scientific activities

11.1.1‌ Scientific events: organisation

General‌​‌ chair, scientific chair
  • Stéphane​​ Gaubert is the adjunct​​​‌ coordinator of the Gaspard‌ Monge Program for Optimization,‌​‌ Operations Research and their​​ interactions with data sciences​​​‌ (PGMO), a corporate sponsorhip‌ program, operated by Fondation‌​‌ Mathématique Jacques Hadamard, supported​​ by EDF, see PGMO​​​‌ site.
Member of‌ the organizing committees
  • Xavier‌​‌ Allamigeon co-organizes the colloquium​​ of CMAP at Ecole​​​‌ polytechnique.
  • Marianne Akian co-organized,‌ with Donato Vasquez-Varas (RICAM)‌​‌ an invited session on​​ “Hamilton-Jacobi equations for optimal​​​‌ control and games: new‌ trends in numerical and‌​‌ analytical aspects”, at the​​ conference VC 2025,​​​‌ Vienna (July 2025).
  • Matias‌ Bender was part of‌​‌ the organization committee of​​ the conference ISSAC 2025​​​‌ as the publicity chair.‌
  • Stéphane​​​‌ Gaubert co-organized, with Guillaume‌ Vigeral (Paris 1), an‌​‌ invited session on “Algebraic​​ and Operator methods for​​​‌ Zero-Sum Games”, at the‌ conference VC 2025,‌​‌ Vienna.

11.1.2 Scientific events:​​ selection

Chair of conference​​​‌ program committees
  • Stéphane Gaubert‌ , co-chair of the‌​‌ PGMO Days 2025, EDF​​ Labs, November, 2025.
  • Stéphane​​​‌ Gaubert co-organized, with Quentin‌ Mérigot (LMO, Orsay), the‌​‌ PGMO lectures (advanced lectures​​ for a research audience)​​​‌ of Daniel Dadush (January‌ 2025) and Peter Buergisser‌​‌ (April 2025), see the​​ PGMO lectures web site​​​‌.
Member of the‌ conference program committees
  • Stéphane‌​‌ Gaubert was member of​​​‌ the Scientific Committee of​ the conference VC 2025​‌, Vienna.

11.1.3 Journal​​

Member of the editorial​​​‌ boards
  • Stéphane Gaubert :​ member of the editorial​‌ board of Journal of​​ Dynamics and Games, Linear​​​‌ and Multilinear Algebra, RAIRO,​ Springer-SMAI book series.

11.1.4​‌ Invited talks

  • Marianne Akian​​ :
    • Talk at the​​​‌ special session on “Real​ and Positive Tropical Geometry”​‌ at the conference SIAM​​ Applied Algebraic Geometry (AG25)​​​‌, Madison, Wisconsin, July​ 2025, on “Solving sparse​‌ tropical polynomial systems by​​ means of parametric mean​​​‌ payoff games” (joint work​ with Antoine Berau et​‌ Stéphane Gaubert).
    • Talk at​​ the “Première rencontre nationale​​​‌ du RT Optimisation”,​ on ”The competitive spectral​‌ radius of families of​​ nonexpansive mappings” (joint work​​​‌ with Stéphane Gaubert, Loïc​ Marchesini, and Ian Morris).​‌
  • Xavier Allamigeon :
    • Plenary​​ talk at the conference​​​‌ ROADEF 2025 (ENPC, Champs-sur-Marne),​ February 2025, on “Simplex-type​‌ complexity bounded for interior​​ point methods”.
    • Talk at​​​‌ Journées Franco-Chiliennes en Optimisation​ (INSA, Rouen), July 2025,​‌ on “Computing stationary solutions​​ of piecewise linear systems​​​‌ with priorities: application to​ emergency departments” (joint work​‌ with P. Capetillo and​​ S. Gaubert).
  • Abdellah Bulaich​​​‌ Mehamdi
    • Talk at VC​ 2025, Vienna (invited​‌ session on "Hamilton-Jacobi equations​​ for optimal control and​​​‌ games: new trends in​ numerical and analytical aspects"),​‌ title: “Duality between polyhedral​​ approximation of value functions​​​‌ and optimal quantization of​ measures” (joint work with​‌ W. van Ackooij, L.​​ Brotcorne, S. Gaubert, Q.​​​‌ Jacquet).
  • Pascal Capetillo :​
    • Talk at the special​‌ session on Computational Tropical​​ geometry, at the conférence​​​‌ SIAM Applied Algebraic Geometry​ (AG25), Madison, Wisconsin,​‌ July 2025, on “Stationary​​ Regimes of Piecewise Linear​​​‌ Dynamical Systems with Priorities​ (joint work with Xavier​‌ Allamigeon and Stéphane Gaubert).​​
  • Stéphane Gaubert :
    • Talk​​​‌ at the special session​ on Computational Tropical geometry,​‌ at the conférence SIAM​​ Applied Algebraic Geometry (AG25)​​​‌, Madison, Wisconsin, July​ 2025, on “Tropical SVMs​‌ via Mean-Payoff Games” (joint​​ work with Xavier Allamigeon,​​​‌ Samuel Boïté and Théo​ Molfessis).
  • Loic Marchesini
    • Talk​‌ at VC 2025,​​ Vienna (invited session on“Algebraic​​​‌ and Operator methods for​ Zero-Sum Games”, title: “The​‌ competitive spectral radius of​​ families of nonexpansive mappings”​​​‌ (joint work with Marianne​ Akian and Stéphane Gaubert).​‌

11.1.5 Additional conferences talks,​​ Seminars

[inline]MA: cette section​​​‌ n'est pas suggeree, on​ la met toujours mais​‌ un peu plus loin,​​ dans une sous-section donc​​​‌ c'est un peu trop,​ je propose de la​‌ mettre ici, il faudrait​​ rajouter tous les exposes​​​‌ de conferences au moins​ ...., j'ai deja rajoute​‌ ceux de Jad et​​ Loic. J'ai aussi rajoute​​​‌ tous les exposes a​ VC2025: ceux de stephane​‌ et moi-meme dans cette​​ section et ceux de​​​‌ Loic et Abdellah dans​ la section precedente.

  • Marianne​‌ Akian
    • Talk at VC​​ 2025, Vienna, title:“Multi-level​​​‌ fast-marching method and semi-Lagrangian​ scheme for the minimum​‌ time problem” (joint work​​ with Shanqing Liu and​​​‌ Stéphane Gaubert).
  • Pascal Capetillo​
    • Talk at HSCC 2025​‌, Irvine, California, USA,​​ May 2025. Title: “Stationary​​​‌ regimes of piecewise linear​ dynamical systems with priorities”​‌ (joint work with X.​​ Allamigeon and S. Gaubert).​​
    • Talk at QEST+FORMATS 2025​​​‌, Aarhus, Denmark, August‌ 2025. Title: “Computing the‌​‌ Congestion Phases of Dynamical​​ Systems with Priorities and​​​‌ Application to Emergency Departments”‌ (joint work with X.‌​‌ Allamigeon and S. Gaubert).​​
  • Stéphane Gaubert
    • Talk VC​​​‌ 2025, Vienna, title:‌ "Extending Markov decision processes:‌​‌ negative probabilities and priority​​ dynamics” (joint work with​​​‌ Xavier Allamigeon and Pascal‌ Capetillo).
  • Loic Marchesini
    • Talk‌​‌ at SMAI 2025 (Carcans,​​ June 2025), title “The​​​‌ competitive spectral radius of‌ families of nonexpansive mappings”‌​‌ (joint work with Marianne​​ Akian and Stéphane Gaubert).​​​‌
    • Talk at CDC 2025‌ (Rio de Janeiro, Dec‌​‌ 2025) , see 24​​.
  • Jad Zeroual
    • Talk​​​‌ at the kick off‌ of the Inria associate‌​‌ team “Tropical Algorithms for​​ Optimization” with CWI (Amsterdam,​​​‌ July 2025), title: “Optimal‌ bidding in Clock-Plus auctions‌​‌ against Straightforward Bidders” (joint​​ work with Marianne Akian,​​​‌ Aurélien Béchler, Matthieu Chardy,‌ Stéphane Gaubert).
    • Poster at‌​‌ the conference “30 ans​​ du séminaire de théorie​​​‌ des jeux” (IHP, Oct‌ 2025), title: “Oracle strategy‌​‌ in Clock-Plus Auctions: Playing​​ with perfect information against​​​‌ Straightforward bidders” (joint work‌ with Marianne Akian, Aurélien‌​‌ Béchler, Matthieu Chardy, Stéphane​​ Gaubert).

11.1.6 Research administration​​​‌

Inria research administration
  • Marianne‌ Akian : Elected member‌​‌ of Inria's Scientific Board.​​
  • Xavier Allamigeon : Elected​​​‌ member of the Committee‌ of the Applied Mathematics‌​‌ Department of Ecole polytechnique​​
  • Matìas Bender : Member​​​‌ of the scientific committee‌ of INRIA Saclay.
Other‌​‌ research administration
  • Marianne Akian​​ : “Secrétaire Générale” of​​​‌ SMAI.
  • Stéphane Gaubert :‌ Member of the Scientific‌​‌ council of École Nationale​​ des Ponts et Chaussées.​​​‌

11.2 Teaching - Supervision‌ - Juries - Educational‌​‌ and pedagogical outreach

11.2.1​​ Teaching

[inline]MA: la section​​​‌ n'existait pas et les‌ cours etaient dans la‌​‌ section “educational...” mais l'enseignement​​ ce n'est pas de​​​‌ la sensibilisation a l'education‌

  • Marianne Akian
    • Course “Markov‌​‌ decision processes: dynamic programming​​ and applications” joint between​​​‌ (3rd year of) ENSTA‌ and M2 “Mathématiques et‌​‌ Applications”, U. Paris Saclay,​​ “Optimization”, 30 hours.
  • Xavier​​​‌ Allamigeon
    • Petites classes et‌ encadrement d'enseignements d'approfondissement de‌​‌ Recherche Opérationnelle en troisième​​ année à l'École Polytechnique​​​‌ (programme d'approfondissement de Mathématiques‌ Appliquées) (niveau M1).
    • Cours‌​‌ “Theoretical Aspects of Linear​​ Programming” du M2 “Optimisation”​​​‌ de l'Université Paris Saclay.‌
    • Cours “Jeux stochastiques” au‌​‌ Master Parisien de Recherche​​ en Informatique.
  • Matias Bender​​​‌
    • Part-time chargé d’enseignement (equivalent‌ to a lecturer, 76‌​‌ hours per year) in​​ the computer science department​​​‌ of École Polytechnique, where‌ he teaches algorithmics courses‌​‌ for the bachelor program​​ in mathematics and computer​​​‌ science.
  • Amanda Bigel
    • Exercises‌ classes for the first‌​‌ year of Bachelor program​​ of Ecole polytechnique in​​​‌ the framework of a‌ “Monitorat”.
  • Pascal Capetillo
    • Exercises‌​‌ classes for the first​​ year of Bachelor program​​​‌ of Ecole polytechnique in‌ the framework of a‌​‌ “Monitorat”.
  • Yiyuan Chen
    • Exercises​​ classes for the first​​​‌ year of Bachelor program‌ of Ecole polytechnique in‌​‌ the framework of a​​ “Monitorat”.
  • Stéphane Gaubert
    • Co-head​​​‌ of the Master “Optimization”‌ of University Paris-Saclay and‌​‌ IPP.
    • Head for IP​​ Paris of the “Mention”​​​‌ (Master Programme) “Mathématiques et‌ Applications” jointly operated by‌​‌ University Paris Saclay and​​​‌ IP Paris.
    • Course “Systèmes​ à Événements Discrets”, option​‌ MAREVA, ENSMP.
    • Course “Algèbre​​ tropicale pour le contrôle​​​‌ optimal et les jeux”​ of “Contrôle, Optimisation et​‌ Calcul des Variations” (COCV)​​ of M2 “Mathématiques et​​​‌ Applications” of Sorbonne University​ and École Polytechnique.
    • Lecture​‌ of Operations Research, third​​ year of École Polytechnique.​​​‌ The lectures notes were​ published as a book​‌  73.

11.2.2 Supervision​​

  • Phd in progress: Chaoping​​​‌ Zhu, codirected by Matías​ Bender and Elias Tsigaridas​‌ (Inria Paris, IMJ-PRG, Sorbonne​​ Université).
  • PhD in progress:​​​‌ Nicolás Alló Gómez, based​ in Argentina, codirected by​‌ Matías Bender and Teresa​​ Krick (University of Buenos​​​‌ Aires, Argentina).
  • PhD defended:​ Quentin Canu, registered at​‌ Univ. Paris Saclay (defense​​ in December 2025), thesis​​​‌ supervisor: Georges Gonthier (INRIA),​ cosupervision: Xavier Allamigeon and​‌ Pierre-Yves Strub (LIX).
  • PhD​​ in progress: Amanda Bigel,​​​‌ registered at IPP (EDMH)​ since September 2022, main​‌ thesis supervisors: Cormac Walsh​​ et Constantin Vernicos, thesis​​​‌ supervisor: Stéphane Gaubert .​
  • PhD in progress: Loïc​‌ Marchesini, registered at IPP​​ (EDMH), since September 2023.​​​‌ Thesis supervisor Marianne Akian​ , co-supervised by Stéphane​‌ Gaubert .
  • PhD in​​ progress: Pascal Capetillo, registered​​​‌ at IPP (EDMH), since​ November 2023. Thesis supervisor:​‌ Stéphane Gaubert , cosupervision:​​ Xavier Allamigeon .
  • PhD​​​‌ in progress: Jonathan Hornewall,​ registered at Marne-la-vallée, ENPC​‌ (maths and STIC), since​​ November 2023. Thesis supervisor:​​​‌ Vincent Leclere, cosupervision: Stéphane​ Gaubert .
  • PhD in​‌ progress: Jad Zeroual, registered​​ at IPP (EDMH), since​​​‌ January 2024. Thesis supervisor​ Marianne Akian , co-supervised​‌ by Stéphane Gaubert ,​​ Aurélien Bechler (Orange Labs)​​​‌ and Mathieu Chardy (Orange​ Labs).
  • PhD in progress:​‌ Yiyuan Chen, registered at​​ IPP (EDMH), since September​​​‌ 2024. Thesis supervisor: Stéphane​ Gaubert , cosupervision: Xavier​‌ Allamigeon .
  • PhD in​​ progress: Abdellah Bulaich, registered​​​‌ at IPP (EDMH), since​ January 2025. Thesis supervisor:​‌ Stéphane Gaubert , cosupervision:​​ Luce Brotcorne (Inria Lille),​​​‌ Wim van Ackooij (EDF),​ Quentin Jacquet (EDF).
  • PhD​‌ in progress: Hélène Arvis,​​ registered at ED “Mathématiques,​​​‌ Sciences et technologies de​ l'information, Informatique” in Grenoble,​‌ since November 2024. Thesis​​ supervisor: Nicolas Gast (Inria​​​‌ Rhône-Alpes), cosupervision: Stéphane Gaubert​ , Bruno Gaujal (Inria​‌ Rhône-Alpes), Olivier Beaude (EDF),​​ Juliette Lesturgie (EDF).
  • Matías​​​‌ Bender co-directed two 3-month​ 2A engineering internships with​‌ G. Artana (Engineering Department,​​ U Buenos Aires) and​​​‌ C. Artana (Oceanography Department,​ Sorbonne U). These internships​‌ were part of an​​ exchange program between the​​​‌ U Buenos Aires, Argentina,​ and SeaTech, Universite ́​‌ de Toulon. This was​​ part of an interdisciplinary​​​‌ proof-of-concept project to study​ eddies using topological data​‌ analysis.

11.2.3 Juries

  • Marianne​​ Akian
    • Member of the​​​‌ hiring committee for a​ junior professor in Optimization​‌ at University Paris 1.​​
    • Member of the hiring​​​‌ committee for a junior​ professor in Optimization or​‌ games at University Paris​​ Dauphine PSL.
    • Jury Chair​​​‌ of the PhD thesis​ of Mohamed Gharafi, Ecole​‌ polytechnique, Octobre 2025.
    • Jury​​ Chair of the PhD​​​‌ thesis of Jules Berry,​ INSA de Rennes, Octobre​‌ 2025.
    • Jury chair of​​ the PhD thesis of​​​‌ Orso Forghieri, Ecole polytechnique,​ décembre 2025.
  • Stéphane Gaubert​‌
    • Jury (reviewer) of the​​ PhD thesis of Davide​​ Zorzenon, Fakultät IV -​​​‌ Electrotechnik und Informatik, TU-Berlin,‌ June 2025.
    • Jury (reviewer)‌​‌ of the PhD thesis​​ of Alaa Ibhrahim, ENS​​​‌ lyon, November 2025.

11.2.4‌ Educational and pedagogical outreach‌​‌

[inline]MA: j'ai mis ca​​ ici, sinon on peut​​​‌ mettre dans la section‌ popularization

11.3 Popularization‌​‌

11.3.1 Others science outreach​​ relevant activities

  • Matias Bender​​​‌ was part of the‌ 2025 outreach campaign of‌​‌ Inria Saclay, where his​​ research was featured in​​​‌ a short communication poster‌ presented at events such‌​‌ as the Science Festival​​ in the southern Paris​​​‌ area.

12 Scientific production‌

12.1 Major publications

  • 1‌​‌ articleM.Marianne Akian​​, S.Stéphane Gaubert​​​‌ and R.Ravindra Bapat‌. Non-archimedean valuations of‌​‌ eigenvalues of matrix polynomials​​.Linear Algebra and​​​‌ its Applications498Also‌ arXiv:1601.00438June 2016,‌​‌ 592--627HALDOI
  • 2​​ articleM.M. Akian​​​‌, S.S. Gaubert‌ and A.A. Guterman‌​‌. Tropical polyhedra are​​ equivalent to mean payoff​​​‌ games.Internat. J.‌ Algebra Comput.221‌​‌2012, 1250001, 43​​URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1142/S0218196711006674DOIback​​​‌ to textback to‌ text
  • 3 articleM.‌​‌Marianne Akian, S.​​Stephane Gaubert and R.​​​‌Roger Nussbaum. Uniqueness‌ of the fixed point‌​‌ of nonexpansive semidifferentiable maps​​.Transactions of the​​​‌ American Mathematical Society368‌2Also arXiv:1201.1536February‌​‌ 2016HALDOIback​​ to textback to​​​‌ textback to text‌
  • 4 articleM.Marianne‌​‌ Akian, S.Stéphane​​ Gaubert and C.Cormac​​​‌ Walsh. The max-plus‌ Martin boundary.Doc.‌​‌ Math.142009,​​ 195--240back to text​​​‌
  • 5 articleX.X.‌ Allamigeon, P.P.‌​‌ Benchimol, S.S.​​ Gaubert and M.M.​​​‌ Joswig. Combinatorial simplex‌ algorithms can solve mean‌​‌ payoff games.SIAM​​ J. Opt.244​​​‌2015, 2096--2117
  • 6‌ articleX.Xavier Allamigeon‌​‌, P.Pascal Benchimol​​, S.Stéphane Gaubert​​​‌ and M.Michael Joswig‌. What Tropical Geometry‌​‌ Tells Us about the​​ Complexity of Linear Programming​​​‌.SIAM Review63‌1February 2021,‌​‌ 123-164HALDOIback​​ to textback to​​​‌ textback to text‌
  • 7 inproceedingsX.X.‌​‌ Allamigeon, S.S.​​ Gaubert, E.E.​​​‌ Goubault, S.S.‌ Putot and N.N.‌​‌ Stott. A scalable​​ algebraic method to infer​​​‌ quadratic invariants of switched‌ systems.Proceedings of‌​‌ the International Conference on​​ Embedded Software (EMSOFT)Best​​​‌ paper award. The extended‌ version of this conference‌​‌ article appeared in \em​​ ACM Trans. Embed. Comput.​​​‌ Syst., 15(4):69:1--69:20, September 2016‌2015back to text‌​‌back to text
  • 8​​ articleJ.J. Bolte​​​‌, S.S. Gaubert‌ and G.G. Vigeral‌​‌. Definable zero-sum stochastic​​ games.Mathematics of​​​‌ Operations Research401‌Also arxiv1301.19672014,‌​‌ 171--191URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1287/moor.2014.0666DOI​​​‌back to text
  • 9​ articleS.S. Friedland​‌, S.Stéphane Gaubert​​ and L.L. Han​​​‌. Perron--Frobenius theorem for​ nonnegative multilinear forms and​‌ extensions.Linear Algebra​​ and its Applications438​​​‌22013, 738-749​HALDOI
  • 10 article​‌S.S. Gaubert and​​ T.Th. Lepoutre.​​​‌ Discrete limit and monotonicity​ properties of the Floquet​‌ eigenvalue in an age​​ structured cell division cycle​​​‌ model.J. Math.​ Biol.2015, URL:​‌ http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00285-015-0874-3DOIback to​​ textback to text​​​‌
  • 11 articleS.S.​ Gaubert and G.G.​‌ Vigeral. A maximin​​ characterization of the escape​​​‌ rate of nonexpansive mappings​ in metrically convex spaces​‌.Math. Proc. of​​ Cambridge Phil. Soc.152​​​‌https://arxiv.org/abs/1012.47652012, 341--363​URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0305004111000673back to​‌ text
  • 12 incollectionC.​​C. Walsh. The​​​‌ horofunction boundary and isometry​ group of the Hilbert​‌ geometry.Handbook of​​ Hilbert Geometry22IRMA​​​‌ Lectures in Mathematics and​ Theoretical PhysicsEuropean Mathematical​‌ Society2014HALback​​ to text

12.2 Publications​​​‌ of the year

International​ journals

International​​ peer-reviewed conferences

Reports & preprints

12.3 Cited publications

  • 37​ inproceedingsM.Marianne Akian​‌, A.Antoine Béreau​​ and S.Stéphane Gaubert​​​‌. Eigenvalue Methods for​ Sparse Tropical Polynomial Systems​‌.Lecture Notes in​​ Computer ScienceICMS 2024​​​‌ - International Congress on​ Mathematical SoftwareDurham, United​‌ KingdomSpringer2024HAL​​back to text
  • 38​​​‌ inproceedingsM.Marianne Akian​, A.Antoine Béreau​‌ and S.Stéphane Gaubert​​. The Tropical Nullstellensatz​​​‌ and Positivstellensatz for Sparse​ Polynomial Systems.ISSAC​‌ '23: Proceedings of the​​ 2023 International Symposium on​​​‌ Symbolic and Algebraic Computation​ISSAC 2023 - International​‌ Symposium on Symbolic and​​ Algebraic ComputationTromsø, Norway​​​‌ACM2023HALDOI​back to text
  • 39​‌ miscM.Marianne Akian​​, J.-P.Jean-Philippe Chancelier​​​‌ and B.Benoît Tran​. Tropical Dynamic Programming​‌ for Lipschitz Multistage Stochastic​​ Programming.December 2020​​​‌HALback to text​back to text
  • 40​‌ articleM.Marianne Akian​​, S.Stéphane Gaubert​​​‌, J.Julien Grand-Clément​ and J.Jérémie Guillaud​‌. The operator approach​​ to entropy games.​​​‌Theory of Computing Systems​https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.051512019HALDOI​‌back to text
  • 41​​ articleM.Marianne Akian​​​‌, S.Stéphane Gaubert​ and A.Antoine Hochart​‌. Generic uniqueness of​​ the bias vector of​​​‌ finite stochastic games with​ perfect information.Journal​‌ of Mathematical Analysis and​​ Applications457https://arxiv.org/abs/1610.096512018​​​‌, 1038-1064HALDOI​back to text
  • 42​‌ miscM.Marianne Akian​​, S.Stéphane Gaubert​​​‌, D.Dariush Kiani​ and H.Hanieh Tavakolipour​‌. Spectral Properties of​​ Positive Definite Matrices over​​ Symmetrized Tropical Algebras and​​​‌ Valued Ordered fields.‌December 2024HALback‌​‌ to text
  • 43 article​​M.Marianne Akian,​​​‌ S.Stéphane Gaubert and‌ S.Shanqing Liu.‌​‌ A Multi-Level Fast-Marching Method​​ For The Minimum Time​​​‌ Problem.SIAM Journal‌ on Control and Optimization‌​‌6262024,​​ 2963-2991HALDOIback​​​‌ to text
  • 44 misc‌M.Marianne Akian,‌​‌ S.Stéphane Gaubert and​​ L.Loïc Marchesini.​​​‌ The Competive Spectral Radius‌ of Families of Nonexpansive‌​‌ Mappings.October 2024​​HALback to text​​​‌
  • 45 miscM.Marianne‌ Akian, S.Stephane‌​‌ Gaubert and L.Louis​​ Rowen. Linear algebra​​​‌ over T-pairs.October‌ 2023HALback to‌​‌ textback to text​​
  • 46 articleM.Marianne​​​‌ Akian, S.Stephane‌ Gaubert and L.Louis‌​‌ Rowen. Semiring systems​​ arising from hyperrings.​​​‌Journal of Pure and‌ Applied Algebra2286‌​‌June 2024, 107584​​HALDOIback to​​​‌ text
  • 47 articleM.‌Marianne Akian, S.‌​‌Stéphane Gaubert and M.​​Meisam Sharify. Log-majorization​​​‌ of the moduli of‌ the eigenvalues of a‌​‌ matrix polynomial by tropical​​ roots.Linear Algebra​​​‌ and its ApplicationsAlso‌ arXiv:1304.29672017HALDOI‌​‌back to text
  • 48​​ articleM.Marianne Akian​​​‌ and S.Stéphane Gaubert‌. Spectral theorem for‌​‌ convex monotone homogeneous maps,​​ and ergodic control.​​​‌Nonlinear Anal.522‌2003, 637--679URL:‌​‌ http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0362-546X(02)00170-0DOIback to​​ text
  • 49 miscM.​​​‌Marianne Akian and S.‌Shanqing Liu. Convergence‌​‌ and Error Estimates of​​ A Semi-Lagrangian scheme for​​​‌ the Minimum Time Problem‌.July 2024HAL‌​‌back to text
  • 50​​ miscX.Xavier Allamigeon​​​‌, A.Abdellah Aznag‌, S.Stéphane Gaubert‌​‌ and Y.Yassine Hamdi​​. The tropicalization of​​​‌ the entropic barrier.‌2020HALback to‌​‌ text
  • 51 articleX.​​Xavier Allamigeon, P.​​​‌Pascal Benchimol, S.‌Stéphane Gaubert and M.‌​‌Michael Joswig. Log-barrier​​ interior point methods are​​​‌ not strongly polynomial.‌SIAM Journal on Applied‌​‌ Algebra and Geometry2​​1https://arxiv.org/abs/1708.01544 - This​​​‌ paper supersedes arXiv:1405.4161. 31‌ pages, 5 figures, 1‌​‌ table2018, 140-178​​HALDOIback to​​​‌ textback to text‌back to text
  • 52‌​‌ inproceedingsX.Xavier Allamigeon​​, P.Pascal Benchimol​​​‌ and S.Stéphane Gaubert‌. The tropical shadow-vertex‌​‌ algorithm solves mean payoff​​ games in polynomial time​​​‌ on average.ICALP‌ 2014857241st International‌​‌ Colloquium, ICALP 2014, Copenhagen,​​ Denmark, July 8-11, 2014,​​​‌ Proceedings, Part ICopenhagen,‌ FranceSpringer2014,‌​‌ 12HALDOIback​​ to text
  • 53 inproceedings​​​‌X.Xavier Allamigeon,‌ V.Vianney Boeuf and‌​‌ S.Stéphane Gaubert.​​ Performance evaluation of an​​​‌ emergency call center: tropical‌ polynomial systems applied to‌​‌ timed Petri nets.​​13th International Conference, Formal​​​‌ Modeling and Analysis of‌ Timed Systems (FORMATS 2015)‌​‌9268Formal Modeling and​​ Analysis of Timed Systems​​​‌Madrid, SpainSpringer2015‌HALDOIback to‌​‌ textback to text​​back to text
  • 54​​​‌ articleX.Xavier Allamigeon‌, V.Vianney Boeuf‌​‌ and S.Stephane Gaubert​​​‌. Stationary solutions of​ discrete and continuous Petri​‌ nets with priorities.​​Performance Evaluation113https://arxiv.org/abs/1612.07661​​​‌2017, 1 -​ 12HALDOIback​‌ to text
  • 55 inproceedings​​X.Xavier Allamigeon,​​​‌ M.Marin Boyet and​ S.Stephane Gaubert.​‌ Computing Transience Bounds of​​ Emergency Call Centers: a​​​‌ Hierarchical Timed Petri Net​ Approach.PETRI NETS​‌ 2022: Application and Theory​​ of Petri Nets and​​​‌ Concurrency13288PETRI NETS​ 2022: Application and Theory​‌ of Petri Nets and​​ Concurrency, Springer Lecture Notes​​​‌ in Computer SciencesBergen,​ NorwaySpringer2022,​‌ 90-112HALDOIback​​ to text
  • 56 article​​​‌X.Xavier Allamigeon,​ M.Marin Boyet and​‌ S.Stéphane Gaubert.​​ Piecewise Affine Dynamical Models​​​‌ of Timed Petri Nets​ -- Application to Emergency​‌ Call Centers.Fundamenta​​ Informaticae1833-42021​​​‌, 169-201HALback​ to text
  • 57 misc​‌X.Xavier Allamigeon,​​ Q.Quentin Canu,​​​‌ C.Cyril Cohen,​ K.Kazuhiko Sakaguchi and​‌ P.-Y.Pierre-Yves Strub.​​ Design patterns of hierarchies​​​‌ for order structures.​February 2023HALback​‌ to text
  • 58 inproceedings​​X.Xavier Allamigeon,​​​‌ Q.Quentin Canu and​ P.-Y.Pierre-Yves Strub.​‌ A Formal Disproof of​​ Hirsch Conjecture.Proceedings​​​‌ of the 12th ACM​ SIGPLAN International Conference on​‌ Certified Programs and Proofs​​CPP 2023 - 12th​​​‌ ACM SIGPLAN International Conference​ on Certified Programs and​‌ ProofsBoston, United States​​ACMJanuary 2023,​​​‌ 17-29HALDOIback​ to text
  • 59 inproceedings​‌X.Xavier Allamigeon,​​ P.Pascal Capetillo and​​​‌ S.Stéphane Gaubert.​ Stationary regimes of piecewise​‌ linear dynamical systems with​​ priorities.Proceedings of​​​‌ the 28th ACM International​ Conference on Hybrid Systems:​‌ Computation and ControlHSCC​​ ’25ACMMay 2025​​​‌, 1–11URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/3716863.3718053​DOIback to text​‌
  • 60 inproceedingsX.Xavier​​ Allamigeon, D.Daniel​​​‌ Dadush, G.Georg​ Loho, B.Bento​‌ Natura and L.Laszlo​​ Vegh. Interior point​​​‌ methods are not worse​ than Simplex.2022​‌ IEEE 63rd Annual Symposium​​ on Foundations of Computer​​​‌ Science (FOCS)Denver, United​ StatesIEEEOctober 2022​‌, 267-277HALDOI​​back to text
  • 61​​​‌ articleX.Xavier Allamigeon​, S.Stéphane Gaubert​‌ and E.Eric Goubault​​. Computing the Vertices​​​‌ of Tropical Polyhedra using​ Directed Hypergraphs.Discrete​‌ and Computational Geometry49​​22013, 247-279​​​‌URL: http://hal.inria.fr/hal-00782862DOIback​ to text
  • 62 incollection​‌X.X. Allamigeon,​​ S.S. Gaubert and​​​‌ É.É. Goubault.​ Inferring Min and Max​‌ Invariants Using Max-plus Polyhedra​​.Proceedings of the​​​‌ 15th International Static Analysis​ Symposium (SAS'08)5079LNCS​‌Valencia, SpainSpringer2008​​, 189--204URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-69166-2_13​​​‌back to textback​ to text
  • 63 article​‌X.Xavier Allamigeon,​​ S.Stéphane Gaubert and​​​‌ F.Frédéric Meunier.​ Tropical Complementarity Problems and​‌ Nash Equilibria.SIAM​​ Journal on Discrete Mathematics​​​‌373August 2023​, 1645--1665URL: https://doi.org/10.1137/21m1446861​‌DOIback to text​​
  • 64 articleX.Xavier​​​‌ Allamigeon, S.Stephane​ Gaubert and M.Mateusz​‌ Skomra. Solving generic​​ nonarchimedean semidefinite programs using​​ stochastic game algorithms.​​​‌Journal of Symbolic Computation‌85An abridged version‌​‌ of this article appeared​​ in the proceedings of​​​‌ ISSAC 20162018,‌ 25-54HALDOIback‌​‌ to text
  • 65 article​​X.Xavier Allamigeon,​​​‌ S.Stéphane Gaubert and‌ M.Mateusz Skomra.‌​‌ Tropical spectrahedra.Discrete​​ and Computational Geometry63​​​‌February 2020, 507–548‌HALDOIback to‌​‌ textback to text​​back to text
  • 66​​​‌ inproceedingsX.Xavier Allamigeon‌, S.Stéphane Gaubert‌​‌ and N.Nicolas Vandame​​. No self-concordant barrier​​​‌ interior point method is‌ strongly polynomial.STOC‌​‌ '22: 54th Annual ACM​​ SIGACT Symposium on Theory​​​‌ of ComputingRome Italy,‌ FranceACMJune 2022‌​‌, 515-528HALDOI​​back to text
  • 67​​​‌ inproceedingsE.E. Asarin‌, J.J. Cervelle‌​‌, A.A. Degorre​​, C.C. Dima​​​‌, F.F. Horn‌ and V.V. Kozyakin‌​‌. Entropy Games and​​ Matrix Multiplication Games.​​​‌Proceedings of the 33rd‌ International Symposium on Theoretical‌​‌ Aspects of Computer Science​​ (STACS)47LIPIcs. Leibniz​​​‌ Int. Proc. Inform.Wadern‌Schloss Dagstuhl--Leibniz-Zentrum für Informatik‌​‌2016, 11:1--11:14back​​ to text
  • 68 book​​​‌F.F. Baccelli,‌ G.G. Cohen,‌​‌ G.-J.G.-J. Olsder and​​ J.-P.J.-P. Quadrat.​​​‌ Synchronization and linearity: an‌ algebra for discrete event‌​‌ systems.Wiley1992​​back to textback​​​‌ to textback to‌ textback to text‌​‌back to textback​​ to text
  • 69 article​​​‌M.Matthew Baker and‌ O.Oliver Lorscheid.‌​‌ Descartes' rule of signs,​​ Newton polygons, and polynomials​​​‌ over hyperfields.J.‌ Algebra5692021,‌​‌ 416--441URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jalgebra.2020.10.024DOI​​back to text
  • 70​​​‌ articleG.G. Barles‌, S.S. Mirrahimi‌​‌ and B.B. Perthame​​. Concentration in Lotka-Volterra​​​‌ parabolic or integral equations:‌ a general convergence result‌​‌.Methods Appl. Anal.​​1632009,​​​‌ 321--340URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.4310/MAA.2009.v16.n3.a4DOI‌back to text
  • 71‌​‌ phdthesisA.Antoine Bereau​​. Tropical Polynomial Systems​​​‌ and Game Theory.‌Ecole polytechniqueNovember 2024‌​‌back to text
  • 72​​ articleV.Vianney Boeuf​​​‌ and P.Philippe Robert‌. A Stochastic Analysis‌​‌ of a Network with​​ Two Levels of Service​​​‌.Queueing Systems92‌3-4https://arxiv.org/abs/1708.095902019,‌​‌ 30HALDOIback​​ to text
  • 73 book​​​‌F.Frédéric Bonnans and‌ S.Stéphane Gaubert.‌​‌ Recherche opérationnelle. Aspects mathématiques​​ et applications.Ellipse​​​‌2016, 391HAL‌back to text
  • 74‌​‌ phdthesisM.M. Boyet​​. Piecewise affine dynamical​​​‌ systems applied to the‌ performance evaluation of emergency‌​‌ call centers.Ecole​​ polytechnique2022, URL:​​​‌ http://www.cmapx.polytechnique.fr/~marin.boyet/These_MB.pdfback to text‌
  • 75 articleP.P.‌​‌ Butkoviċ. Max-algebra: the​​ linear algebra of combinatorics?​​​‌Linear Algebra and its‌ applications3672003,‌​‌ 313--335back to text​​
  • 76 bookP.Peter​​​‌ Butkoviċ. Max-linear systems:‌ theory and algorithms.‌​‌Springer Monographs in Mathematics​​Springer-Verlag London, Ltd., London​​​‌2010, xviii+272URL:‌ http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-1-84996-299-5DOIback to‌​‌ textback to text​​
  • 77 inproceedingsJ.J.​​​‌ Cochet-Terrasson, G.G.‌ Cohen, S.S.‌​‌ Gaubert, M. M.​​​‌M. Mc Gettrick and​ J.-P.J.-P. Quadrat.​‌ Numerical computation of spectral​​ elements in max-plus algebra​​​‌.Proc. of the​ IFAC Conference on System​‌ Structure and ControlNantes​​1998back to text​​​‌
  • 78 articleG.Guy​ Cohen, S.Stéphane​‌ Gaubert and J.-P.Jean-Pierre​​ Quadrat. Max-plus algebra​​​‌ and system theory: where​ we are and where​‌ to go now.​​Annual Reviews in Control​​​‌231999, 207--219​back to text
  • 79​‌ articleA.Alain Connes​​ and C.Caterina Consani​​​‌. Geometry of the​ arithmetic site.Adv.​‌ Math.2912016,​​ 274--329back to text​​​‌
  • 80 articleP.P.​ Cousot and R.R.​‌ Cousot. Abstract Interpretation:​​ A unified lattice model​​​‌ for static analysis of​ programs by construction of​‌ approximations of fixed points​​.Principles of Programming​​​‌ Languages 41977,​ 238--252back to text​‌back to text
  • 81​​ incollectionD.Daniel Delling​​​‌, P.Peter Sanders​, D.Dominik Schultes​‌ and D.Dorothea Wagner​​. Highway hierarchies star​​​‌.The shortest path​ problem74DIMACS Ser.​‌ Discrete Math. Theoret. Comput.​​ Sci.Amer. Math. Soc.,​​​‌ Providence, RI2009,​ 141--174back to text​‌
  • 82 articleA.Albert​​ Fathi and A.Antonio​​​‌ Siconolfi. Existence of​ C 1 critical subsolutions​‌ of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation​​.Invent. Math.155​​​‌22004, 363--388​URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00222-003-0323-6DOIback​‌ to text
  • 83 article​​O.Olivier Fercoq,​​​‌ M.Marianne Akian,​ M.Mustapha Bouhtou and​‌ S.Stephane Gaubert.​​ Ergodic control and polyhedral​​​‌ approaches to PageRank optimization​.IEEE Trans. Automat.​‌ Control5812013​​, 134--148URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TAC.2012.2226103​​​‌DOIback to text​
  • 84 articleW.W.H.​‌ Fleming and W.W.M.​​ McEneaney. A max-plus​​​‌ based algorithm for an​ HJB equation of non-linear​‌ filtering.SIAM J.​​ Control and Opt.2000​​​‌, 683--710back to​ text
  • 85 articleS.​‌S. Fomin and A.​​A. Zelevinsky. Cluster​​​‌ algebras. I. Foundations.​J. Amer. Math. Soc.​‌1522002,​​ 497--529URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/math.RT/0104151back​​​‌ to text
  • 86 inproceedings​S.S. Gaubert,​‌ E.E. Goubault,​​ A.A. Taly and​​​‌ S.S. Zennou.​ Static Analysis by Policy​‌ Iteration in Relational Domains​​.Proceedings of the​​​‌ Proc. of the 16th​ European Symposium on Programming​‌ (ESOP'07)4421LNCSBraga​​ (Portugal)Springer2007,​​​‌ 237--252URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-71316-6_17DOI​back to text
  • 87​‌ inproceedingsS.S. Gaubert​​, W.W.M. McEneaney​​​‌ and Z.Z. Qu​. Curse of dimensionality​‌ reduction in max-plus based​​ approximation methods: theoretical estimates​​​‌ and improved pruning algorithms​.Proceedings of the​‌ 50th IEEE Conference on​​ Decision and Control and​​​‌ European Control Conference (CDC-ECC​ 11)Orlando, FL, USA​‌2011, 1054-1061URL:​​ http://arxiv.org/abs/1109.5241back to text​​​‌
  • 88 incollectionS.S.​ Gaubert and M.M.​‌ Sharify. Tropical scaling​​ of polynomial matrices.​​​‌Positive systems389Lecture​ Notes in Control and​‌ Inform. Sci.BerlinSpringer​​2009, 291--303URL:​​​‌ http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-02894-6_28back to text​
  • 89 miscS.Stephane​‌ Gaubert and Y.Yiannis​​ Vlassopoulos. Relu and​​ softplus neural nets as​​​‌ zero-sum turn-based games.‌arXiv:2512.205822025back to‌​‌ text
  • 90 articleT.​​ M.T. M. Gawlitza​​​‌, H.H. Seidl‌, A.A. Adjé‌​‌, S.S. Gaubert​​ and E.E. Goubault​​​‌. Abstract interpretation meets‌ convex optimization.J.‌​‌ Symbolic Comput.4712​​Special issue on Invariant​​​‌ generation and reasoning about‌ loops2012, 1416--1446‌​‌URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jsc.2011.12.048DOIback​​ to text
  • 91 book​​​‌I. M.I. M.‌ Gelfand, M. M.‌​‌M. M. Kapranov and​​ A. V.A. V.​​​‌ Zelevinsky. Discriminants, resultants‌ and multidimensional determinants.‌​‌Modern Birkhäuser ClassicsReprint​​ of the 1994 edition​​​‌Birkhäuser Boston, Inc., Boston,‌ MA2008, x+523‌​‌back to text
  • 92​​ inbookV.Vasilis Gkatzelis​​​‌, D.Daniel Schoepflin‌ and X.Xizhi Tan‌​‌. Clock Auctions Augmented​​ with Unreliable Advice.​​​‌Proceedings of the 2025‌ Annual ACM-SIAM Symposium on‌​‌ Discrete Algorithms (SODA)2629-2655​​URL: https://epubs.siam.org/doi/abs/10.1137/1.9781611978322.86DOIback​​​‌ to text
  • 93 unpublished‌T.Thomas Haettel,‌​‌ A.-S.Anna-Sofie Schilling,​​ A.Anna Wienhard and​​​‌ C.Cormac Walsh.‌ Horofunction Compactifications of Symmetric‌​‌ Spaces.2018,​​ https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.05026 - working paper​​​‌ or preprintHALback‌ to text
  • 94 article‌​‌S.Sven Hammarling,​​ C. J.Christopher J.​​​‌ Munro and F.Françoise‌ Tisseur. An algorithm‌​‌ for the complete solution​​ of quadratic eigenvalue problems​​​‌.ACM Trans. Math.‌ Software3932013‌​‌, Art. 18, 19​​URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/2450153.2450156DOIback​​​‌ to text
  • 95 book‌B.Bernd Heidergott,‌​‌ G. J.Geert Jan​​ Olsder and J.Jacob​​​‌ van der Woude.‌ Max Plus at Work:‌​‌ Modeling and Analysis of​​ Synchronized Systems: A Course​​​‌ on Max-Plus Algebra and‌ Its Applications.Princeton‌​‌2005back to text​​
  • 96 articleP. A.​​​‌Paul Alexander Helminck and‌ Y.Yue Ren.‌​‌ Generic root counts and​​ flatness in tropical geometry​​​‌.arXiv preprint arXiv:2206.07838‌2022back to text‌​‌
  • 97 inproceedingsJ.Jonathan​​ Hornewall, S.Solène​​​‌ Delannoy‐Pavy, V.Vincent‌ Leclère and T.Tito‌​‌ Homem‐De‐Mello. Decision Focused​​ Scenario Generation for Contextual​​​‌ Two‐Stage Stochastic Linear Programming‌.NeurIPS 2025 Workshop‌​‌ on ML×OR: Mathematical Foundations​​ and Operational Integration of​​​‌ Machine Learning for Uncertainty‐Aware‌ Decision‐Making2025, URL:‌​‌ https://openreview.net/forum?id=j8BVbta5lgback to text​​
  • 98 articleH.Hitoshi​​​‌ Ishii and H.Hiroyoshi‌ Mitake. Representation formulas‌​‌ for solutions of Hamilton-Jacobi​​ equations with convex Hamiltonians​​​‌.Indiana Univ. Math.‌ J.5652007‌​‌, 2159--2183URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1512/iumj.2007.56.3048​​DOIback to text​​​‌
  • 99 bookI.I.‌ Itenberg, G.G.‌​‌ Mikhalkin and E.E.​​ Shustin. Tropical algebraic​​​‌ geometry.35Oberwolfach‌ SeminarsBaselBirkhäuser Verlag‌​‌2007, viii+103back​​ to text
  • 100 book​​​‌V.V.N. Kolokoltsov and‌ V.V.P. Maslov.‌​‌ Idempotent analysis and applications​​.Kluwer Acad. Publisher​​​‌1997back to text‌
  • 101 bookB.B.‌​‌ Lemmens and R.R.​​ Nussbaum. Nonlinear Perron-Frobenius​​​‌ theory.189Cambridge‌ Tracts in MathematicsCambridge‌​‌ University Press, Cambridge2012​​, xii+323URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139026079​​​‌DOIback to text‌
  • 102 miscB.Bas‌​‌ Lemmens and C.Cormac​​​‌ Walsh. Distance-preserving maps​ between bounded symmetric domains​‌.2024HALback​​ to text
  • 103 phdthesis​​​‌S.Shanqing Liu.​ Highway Hierarchies for HJB​‌ Equations.Ecole polytechnique​​December 2023back to​​​‌ text
  • 104 articleQ.​Q. Lu, M.​‌M. Madsen, M.​​M. Milata, S.​​​‌S. Ravn, U.​U. Fahrenberg and K.​‌ G.K. G. Larsen​​. Reachability Analysis for​​​‌ Timed Automata using Max-Plus​ Algebra.J. Logic​‌ Alg. Prog.813​​2012, 298-313back​​​‌ to text
  • 105 book​V.V.P. Maslov.​‌ Méthodes Operatorielles.Moscou​​Edition Mir1987back​​​‌ to textback to​ text
  • 106 articleW.​‌ M.W. M. McEneaney​​. A curse-of-dimensionality-free numerical​​​‌ method for solution of​ certain HJB PDEs.​‌SIAM J. Control Optim.​​4642007,​​​‌ 1239--1276URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1137/040610830DOI​back to textback​‌ to text
  • 107 inproceedings​​W.W.M. McEneaney,​​​‌ A.A. Deshpande and​ S.S. Gaubert.​‌ Curse-of-Complexity Attenuation in the​​ Curse-of-Dimensionality-Free Method for HJB​​​‌ PDEs.Proc. of​ the 2008 American Control​‌ ConferenceSeattle, Washington, USA​​2008back to text​​​‌
  • 108 bookW. M.​William M. McEneaney.​‌ Max-plus methods for nonlinear​​ control and estimation.​​​‌Systems & Control: Foundations​ & ApplicationsBoston, MA​‌Birkhäuser Boston Inc.2006​​, xiv+241back to​​​‌ text
  • 109 bookJ.-F.​J.-F. Mertens, S.​‌S. Sorin and S.​​S. Zamir. Repeated​​​‌ Games.Cambridge2015​back to text
  • 110​‌ articleG.G. Mikhalkin​​. Enumerative tropical algebraic​​​‌ geometry in 2 .​J. Amer. Math. Soc.​‌1822005,​​ 313--377URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1090/S0894-0347-05-00477-7DOI​​​‌back to text
  • 111​ articleR. H.Rolf​‌ H. Möhring, M.​​Martin Skutella and F.​​​‌Frederik Stork. Scheduling​ with AND/OR precedence constraints​‌.SIAM J. Comput.​​3322004,​​​‌ 393--415URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1137/S009753970037727XDOI​back to text
  • 112​‌ bookA.A. Papadopoulos​​. Metric spaces, convexity​​​‌ and non-positive curvature.​6IRMA Lectures in​‌ Mathematics and Theoretical Physics​​European Mathematical Society (EMS),​​​‌ Zürich2014, xii+309​URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.4171/132DOIback​‌ to text
  • 113 article​​M. V.M. V.​​​‌ F. Pereira and L.​ M.L. M. V.​‌ G. Pinto. Multi-stage​​ stochastic optimization applied to​​​‌ energy planning.Math.​ Programming522, Ser.​‌ B1991, 359--375​​URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF01582895DOIback​​​‌ to text
  • 114 incollection​J.-E.J.-E. Pin.​‌ Tropical Semirings.Idempotency​​11Publications of the​​​‌ Isaac Newton InstituteCambridge​ University Press1998,​‌ 50–69back to text​​
  • 115 inproceedingsM.M.​​​‌ Plus. Linear systems​ in (max,+) algebra.​‌Proceedings of the 29th​​ IEEE Conference on Decision​​​‌ and ControlIEEE1990​, 151--156back to​‌ textback to text​​
  • 116 incollectionM.Max​​​‌ Plus. Max-plus-times linear​ systems.Open Problems​‌ in Mathematical Systems and​​ Control TheoryMax Plus​​​‌ is a collective name​ for M. Akian, G.​‌ Cohen, S. Gaubert, J.P.​​ Quadrat and M. Viot​​​‌Springer1999, 167--170​back to text
  • 117​‌ phdthesisZ.Zheng Qu​​. Théorie de Perron-Frobenius​​ non linéaire et méthodes​​​‌ numériques max-plus pour la‌ résolution d'équations d'Hamilton-Jacobi.‌​‌Ecole Polytechnique X2013​​, URL: http://hal.inria.fr/pastel-00927122back​​​‌ to text
  • 118 article‌D.D. Reeb,‌​‌ M. J.M. J.​​ Kastoryano and M. M.​​​‌M. M. Wolf.‌ Hilbert's projective metric in‌​‌ quantum information theory.​​J. Math. Phys.52​​​‌82011, 082201,‌ 33URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.3615729DOI‌​‌back to text
  • 119​​ incollectionJ.J. Richter-Gebert​​​‌, B.B. Sturmfels‌ and T.T. Theobald‌​‌. First steps in​​ tropical geometry.Idempotent​​​‌ mathematics and mathematical physics‌377Contemp. Math.Providence,‌​‌ RIAmer. Math. Soc.​​2005, 289--317back​​​‌ to text
  • 120 incollection‌G.G. Sagnol,‌​‌ S.S. Gaubert and​​ M.M. Bouhtou.​​​‌ Optimal monitoring on large‌ networks by Successive c-Optimal‌​‌ Designs.Proceedings of​​ the 22nd international teletraffic​​​‌ congress (ITC22), Amsterdam, The‌ Netherlands, Septemberhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1109/ITC.2010.5608717IEEE‌​‌2010back to text​​
  • 121 articleP.Peter​​​‌ Sanders and D.Dominik‌ Schultes. Engineering highway‌​‌ hierarchies.ACM J.​​ Exp. Algorithmics172012​​​‌, Article 1.6, 40‌URL: https://doi.org/10.1145/2133803.2330080DOIback‌​‌ to text
  • 122 inproceedings​​S.S. Sankaranarayanan,​​​‌ H.H. Sipma and‌ Z.Z. Manna.‌​‌ Scalable Analysis of Linear​​ Systems using Mathematical Programming​​​‌.VMCAI3385LNCS‌2005back to text‌​‌
  • 123 inproceedingsR.R.​​ Sepulchre, A.A.​​​‌ Sarlette and P.P.‌ Rouchon. Consensus in‌​‌ noncommutative spaces.Proceedings​​ of the 49th IEEE​​​‌ Conference on Decision and‌ ControlAtlanta, USA2010‌​‌, 6596-6601URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/CDC.2010.5717072​​back to text
  • 124​​​‌ inproceedingsI.I. Simon‌. Limited subsets of‌​‌ a free monoid.​​Proc. 19th Annual Symposium​​​‌ on Foundations of Computer‌ SciencePiscataway, NJ1978‌​‌, 143--150back to​​ text
  • 125 bookH.​​​‌ L.H. L. Smith‌. Monotone dynamical systems‌​‌.41Mathematical Surveys​​ and MonographsAn introduction​​​‌ to the theory of‌ competitive and cooperative systems‌​‌American Mathematical Society, Providence,​​ RI1995, x+174​​​‌back to text
  • 126‌ phdthesisD.-N.Duy-Nghi Tran‌​‌. Programmation dynamique tropicale​​ en optimisation stochastique multi-étapes​​​‌.Université Paris-Est2020‌HALback to text‌​‌
  • 127 articleN. M.​​Ngoc Mai Tran and​​​‌ J.Josephine Yu.‌ Product-Mix Auctions and Tropical‌​‌ Geometry.Math. O.R.​​444arXiv:1505.057372019​​​‌, 1396--1411back to‌ text
  • 128 phdthesisN.‌​‌Nicolas Vandame. Convergence​​ Estimates in Tropical Geometry​​​‌ and Application in Optimization‌.Ecole polytechnique2024‌​‌back to textback​​ to text
  • 129 incollection​​​‌O.O. Viro.‌ Dequantization of real algebraic‌​‌ geometry on logarithmic paper​​.European Congress of​​​‌ Mathematics, Vol. I (Barcelona,‌ 2000)201Progr. Math.‌​‌BaselBirkhäuser2001,​​ 135--146back to text​​​‌back to textback‌ to text
  • 130 article‌​‌C.Cormac Walsh.​​ Gauge-reversing maps on cones,​​​‌ and Hilbert and Thompson‌ isometries.Geometry and‌​‌ Topology221https://arxiv.org/abs/1312.7871​​ - Preprint arXiv:1312.78712018​​​‌, 55-104HALback‌ to text
  • 131 article‌​‌C.Cormac Walsh.​​ Order antimorphisms of finite-dimensional​​​‌ cones.Selecta Mathematica‌ (New Series)264‌​‌2020, paper number​​​‌ 53HALback to​ text